A reliable evaluation of the integral giving the hadronic vacuum polarization contribution to the muon anomalous magnetic moment should be possible using a simple trapezoid-rule integration of lattice data for the subtracted electromagnetic current polarization function in the Euclidean momentum interval Q 2 > Q 2 min , coupled with an N -parameter Padé or other representation of the polarization in the interval 0 < Q 2 < Q 2 min , for sufficiently high Q 2 min and sufficiently large N . Using a physically motivated model for the I = 1 polarization, and the covariance matrix from a recent lattice simulation to generate associated fake "lattice data," we show that systematic errors associated with the choices of Q 2 min and N can be reduced to well below the 1% level for Q 2 min as low as 0.1 GeV 2 and rather small N . For such low Q 2 min , both an NNLO chiral representation with one additional NNNLO term and a low-order polynomial expansion employing a conformally transformed variable also provide representations sufficiently accurate to reach this precision for the low-Q 2 contribution. Combined with standard techniques for reducing other sources of error on the lattice determination, this hybrid strategy thus looks to provide a promising approach to reaching the goal of a sub-percent precision determination 2 of the hadronic vacuum polarization contribution to the muon anomalous magnetic moment on the lattice.