“…In Figure , we attempted to show that high Fe(III) content in the Sherwood cores could explain the elevated values and justify the use of a separate for these cores; however, Figure also shows high Fe(III) content for AC and PB, cores that do not display elevated values in Figure b, suggesting that Fe(III) content alone cannot be used to justify using an additional parameter. Accounting for the uncertainty in k models resulting from the choice of and is essential before these k models can be applied in the field and future work should focus on nonsandstone materials (e.g., carbonates [e.g., Halisch et al ., ; Schoenfelder et al ., ], unconsolidated sediments [e.g., Weller et al ., ; Dlugosch et al ., ]) with a range of mineralogies.…”