Tuberculosis as a three-act play: A new paradigm for the pathogenesis of pulmonary tuberculosis

Abstract

Lack of access to human tissues with untreated tuberculosis (TB) has forced generations of researchers to use animal models and to adopt a paradigm that granulomas are the characteristic lesion of both primary and post primary TB. An extended search of studies of human lung tissues failed to find any reports that support this paradigm. We found scores of publications from gross pathology in 1804 through high resolution CT scans in 2015 that identify obstructive lobular pneumonia, not granulomas, as the characteristic lesion of developing post-primary TB. This paper reviews this literature together with other relevant observations to formulate a new paradigm of TB with three distinct stages: a three-act play. First, primary TB, a war of attrition, begins with infection that spreads via lymphatics and blood stream before inducing systemic immunity that contains and controls the organisms within granulomas. Second, post-primary TB, a sneak attack, develops during latent TB as an asymptomatic obstructive lobular pneumonia in persons with effective systemic immunity. It is a paucibacillary process with no granulomas that spreads via bronchi and accumulates mycobacterial antigens and host lipids for 1–2 years before suddenly undergoing caseous necrosis. Third, the fallout, is responsible for nearly all clinical post primary disease. It begins with caseous necrotic pneumonia that is either retained to become the focus of fibrocaseous disease or is coughed out to leave a cavity. This three-stage paradigm suggests testable hypotheses and plausible answers to long standing questions of immunity to TB.

Tuberculosis: An Infection-Initiated Autoimmune Disease?

“…Similarly, in rabbit models, cavitation is accelerated by pre-sensitisation with purified protein derivative (PPD) to drive a strong delayed-type hypersensitivity reaction, but inhibited by immunosuppression. Immunity is thought to be directed against Mtb antigens, with progressive accumulation of total mycobacterial antigenic load over time precipitating inflammation and lung tissue destruction [2]. However, a striking feature of TB granulomas is the paucity of mycobacteria, while extensive pathology develops.…”

René Dubos, tuberculosis, and the “ecological facets of virulence”

“…However, scientists are still unable to explain why immunity to infection does not enable susceptible humans to resolve lung function and prevent development of the disease (Hunter 2016). …”

A biosafety algorithm for the protection of pathology staff during intraoperative examinations of pulmonary lesions

“…">Pathology staff must put on an N‐95 face mask with a cap and disposable gloves in addition to a disposable gown and a face guard before handling surgically obtained pulmonary material (Fig. d) …”