Troubling the Essentialist Discourse ofBrownin Education: The Anti-Black Sociopolitical and Sociohistorical Etymology of Latinxs as aBrownMonolith

Abstract

US-based scholars often colloquially employ Brown as a monolithic reference to Latinidad in education research without attention to its racialized and anti-Black underpinnings. In this conceptual essay, we apprehend the currents of hemispheric racial formation within a South–North orientation to problematize the essentialist ethos of US Latinxs as monolithically Brown. To do so, we briefly trace the anti-Black sociohistorical and sociopolitical etymology of a uniform Brown Latinx identity as a byproduct of colonial logics and homogenizing political philosophies in Latin America such as mestizaje and racial democracy. In conclusion, we offer implications for theorizing Latinidades in educational research that moves beyond mestizaje and colonial logics to consider Afro-Latinx, Afro-Latin American, and Indigenous Latinx subjectivities.

Income & Campus Disparities Among Hispanic-Identifying UC Applicants: Implications for Hispanic Serving Institution Designation

“…Our findings suggest that the ambiguous nature of the Hispanic category allows not only organizations to meet institutional goals of serving Hispanic-identifying students (Mora 2014), but also provides applicants with latitude in defining their ethnic identity. These findings contribute to the burgeoning discourse on how university depictions of ethnoracial diversity are often augmented by creative quantification and categorization strategies, as well as unclear racial and ethnic boundaries (Byrd 2021;Busey & Silva, 2021;Ford and Patterson 2018).…”

Performing Anti-racism: Universities Respond to Anti-Black Violence

“…Following a preliminary review, a sentence-by-sentence analysis considered terms, phrases, and components with multiple or hidden meanings. Coupled with an explicit consideration of race (Busey & Silva, 2021), the coding followed in-vivo coding to identify salient phrases related to campus racial equity (Saldaña, 2021). This analysis was enhanced by the use of memoing and reflection to address the potential bias and increase the study's trustworthiness of the analysis (Creswell & Poth, 2016; Merriam & Tisdell, 2015).…”

“…This research utilized CRDA; informed by prior analyzes, which drew together CRT within CDA (Busey & Silva, 2021;Casellas Connors, 2021). First, the quantitative textual analysis addressed the features and contours of the data.…”

Examining racial discourse in equity reports: Florida’s public Hispanic serving institutions

“…These shifts have captured how "the term 'diversity' is used in multiple contexts serving myriad functions" (Harris et al, 2015, p. 24). Narratives considering Latinx students have taken up a discourse of "browning," which serves to distance Latinidad from Blackness (Busey & Silva, 2020), informed by the political tax associated with explicitly racialized discourse. Capturing how racial policy discourse draws a largely negative response shaped by White individuals perceptions that discussions of race run counter to egalitarian values (Huber & Lapinski, 2006;Mendelberg, 2017).…”