Troubling distinctions: a semiotics of the nursing/technology relationship

Abstract

I consider the discursive practices that have served conceptually and ontologically to trouble the boundaries between nursing and technology: between nurse/human/subject and machine/non-human/object. Nursing and technology have been semiotically related largely by two processes: (a) by the metaphor that depicts nursing as technology and (b) by opposition, or as not like and even in conflict with technology. Less frequently but no less significantly, nursing and technology have been semiotically linked (c) by the metaphor that depicts technology as nursing and (d) by metonymy, or by word or picture juxtapositions of nursing with technology. The troubling distinctions between nursing and technology suggest yet another reason why the construction of difference continues to elude nursing.

Complexity in Non-Pharmacological Caregiving Activities at the End of Life: An International Qualitative Study

“…It is notable that when activities refer to talking about subjects that are not specifically disease- or problem-focused, they tended to be trivialized by use of diminutive terms, e.g., “chatting.” Such terminology does not acknowledge these contacts as central in providing an understanding needed to transfer general principles into the situation-specific knowledge underlying the provision of patient/person-centered care. This can be seen as parallel to a societal tendency to view technological and medical treatments as having higher status than non-pharmacological caregiving [25]. Similarly, bodily care for the dying person is often conceptualized as “basic” care [26].…”

Nursing Informatics: Decades of Contribution to Health Informatics

“…The introduction and use of new technology to support nurses in their care for patients always leads to change and the development of new service repertoires [1]. Changes and innovations contribute to specialization of health care, nursing care, and treatment, and should stimulate discussions of how to harness opportunities, handle dilemmas, and prevent harm from automation during such transitional periods.…”

Technology and the Bedside Nurse

“…2 As new technologies accumulated in hospitals and patient care areas, nurses were charged with mastering them. 3,4 By the mid 1900s, the pace of technological development in the health sector had increased significantly, as had the development of formal nursing education programs and the number of hospitals in America. 5 I think there is a worldwide market for maybe five computers.…”