Troubling Conceptions of Motherhood

Abstract

This chapter explores the ways in which political institutions in three countries—Egypt, Sri Lanka, and Argentina—interact with religious and cultural conceptions of motherhood to provide women with social authority, often through respectability politics. State and societal dynamics in each case forced women to bargain with patriarchy in order to secure political gains using—and therefore reproducing—respectability politics. In each of these three cases from different geographical regions of the world, the authors’ analysis has revealed how women’s “bargaining with patriarchy” by employing patriarchal discourses on respectable femininity and maternal identities enabled some women to engage, challenge, and resist the state. By using respectability politics centered around maternalism and the institution of motherhood, women have helped to advance democratization by challenging human rights abuses and/or furthered women’s participation in politics. With these three cases, the chapter demonstrates how, in certain political and cultural contexts where religion and women’s roles as the foundation of the family significantly structure the lives of women, motherhood has been utilized as a powerful tool for political mobilization and contestation.

Disrupting the Saviour Politics in the Women, Peace and Security Agenda in the Global South: Grassroots Women Creating Gender Norms in Nepal and Sri Lanka

“…We suggest that motherhood is not only a strategic choice that results in expedient political outcomes, but that mobilising through motherhood challenges pervasive gender norms that presume mothers are inherently weak, passive and/or socially conservative. Furthermore, many women across diverse societies receive respect for their status as mothers indicating that motherhood can provide a place to advocate for women's respect and political inclusion (Mhajne & Whetstone, 2020). The innovative gender norms that grassroots Sri Lankan women have constructed around motherhood provide models for other women globally, particularly in politically challenging environments.…”