Trophic partitioning among seasonally resident predators in a temperate estuary

Abstract

Many migratory coastal shark species enter temperate estuaries seasonally, tracking suitable environmental conditions (i.e. temperature) and food resources. Understanding the functional role that migratory sharks play in coastal food webs depends on information regarding the distinctness among predators’ trophic ecology. We examined the trophic ecology of 4 species of coastal sharks (Atlantic sharpnose, n = 22; bonnethead, n = 29; blacktip, n = 8; blacknose, n = 28) that migrate into temperate coastal ecosystems of the northwest Atlantic Ocean during the summer. We quantified their trophic relationships using bulk stable isotope ratios (δ13C, δ15N, and δ34S) measured in 2 tissue types representing long-term (red blood cells; 8-10 mo) and short-term (blood plasma; 10-13 wk) metabolic turnover. The primary carbon sources for the 4 shark species, determined via stable isotope mixing models, were consistently phytoplankton (mean ± SD: 65.8 ± 4.8%) and microphytobenthos (18.6 ± 5.4%), regardless of tissue type. However, interspecific isotopic niche overlap between any 2 species ranged widely (0-92%). The niche space occupied exclusively by one species also varied considerably but was lowest for blacktips (<20%) and highest for bonnetheads (>90%). Isotopic niche size estimated using short-term tissues, was substantially larger for 3 of the 4 species (Atlantic sharpnose, 41% increase; blacknose, 140%; blacktips, 159%) than long-term tissues. These data suggest species-specific trophic redundancy and increasing overlap in the summer months, indicated by larger isotopic niches during estuarine residency. As coastal habitats become increasingly altered, understanding the functional diversity of predators is vital for the prediction and assessment of resulting ecosystem-level change.