“…Nucleotide bases have been recognized as identity elements in interaction of tRNAs with synthetases (Normanly & Abelson, 1989;Söll & RajBhandary, 1995)+ 29-Hydroxyl groups have also been shown to play a role in this process+ These experiments were based on a complete exchange of all 29-deoxy groups in the molecule (Khan & Roe, 1988) or just one of the four nucleotides (Aphasizhev et al+, 1997)+ Additionally, kinetic analysis of single 29-deoxy-modified positions in minihelices or tRNA fragments of tRNA Ala or tRNA Pro showed small but distinct effects in aminoacylation efficiency (Musier-Forsyth & Schimmel, 1992;Yap & Musier-Forsyth, 1995)+ We were interested in an in vitro scanning procedure which should rapidly identify such 29-deoxy-sensitive sites in a complete tRNA rather than testing individual positions in a stepwise fashion+ The E. coli tRNA Asp system was chosen because it offered the opportunity to compare the results with an X-ray structural model still under final refinement (L+ Moulinier & D+ Moras, pers+ comm+)+ Although the simplest method for scanning a tRNA for the importance of 29-hydroxyl groups for aminoacylation should be the random incorporation of 29-deoxynucleotides, the identification of the interfering positions by limited alkaline hydrolysis proved impractical in our system because of high background of cleavage, even though this procedure had been applied to a 15-nt-long tRNA anticodon stem-loop fragment to test ribosomal A site binding (von Ahsen et al+, 1997)+ We therefore chose to couple the 29-deoxy modification with a phosphorothioate modification that generates a signal only at the deoxy positions upon iodine cleavage (Gish & Eckstein, 1988) and thus facilitates the 29-deoxy identification+ As any interference observed with this double modification could result from the deoxy and/or the phosphorothioate substitutions, the effect of the phosphorothioate modification was determined separately by transcribing the E. coli tRNA Asp with dNTPaS or NTPaS+ Both pools were then charged with the cognate synthetase and a tRNAs were ligated using one unmodified half and one half containing the deoxynucleotide at the identified position as described in Materials and Methods+ Each measurement was repeated at least twice+ Error Յ 20%+ (Gish & Eckstein, 1988;Schatz et al+, 1991;Verma & Eckstein, 1998)+ Because the incorporation of the analogues is random, this approach does not rely on any assumption about which positions might be important and thus differs from the previous studies+ In the scanning experiments positions U11, A24, U25, C28, U29, C36, C48, G57, A58, and C67 showed only a deoxy effect+ All others were accompanied by considerable phosphorothioate interference+ At G34, C74, and C75 the deoxy effect on top of the phosphorothioate interference was considered strong enough to be indicative of an additional effect+ The only position where the phosphorothioate effect was stronger than the deoxy effect was U35, the central position of the anticodon+ However, in general, comparison between these two effects is made difficult by the fact that the amount of dNTPaS and NTPaS incorporation is not necessarily the same+ The assignment of deoxy effects was therefore conservative+…”