The geochemical behavior of nickel, an essential trace metal element, strongly depends on its interactions with Mn oxides. Interactions between the phyllomanganate birnessite and sorbed or structurally incorporated Ni have been extensively documented together with the fate of Ni along the transformation of these layered species to tunnel Mn oxides (tectomanganates). By contrast, interactions of phyllomanganates with weakly bound Ni species (hydrated Ni, Ni (hydr)oxides), that possibly prevail in natural Ni-rich (>10% NiO) manganates received little attention and the influence of these Ni species on the phyllomanganate-to-tectomanganate transformation remains essentially unknown. Within this framework, a set of phyllomanganate precursors with contrasting contents of Ni were prepared and subjected to a reflux process mimicking the natural phyllomanganate-to-tectomanganate conversion. Layered precursors and reflux products were characterized with a combination of diffractometric, spectroscopic, thermal, and chemical methods. Ni is essentially present as hydrated Ni(II) and Ni(II) (hydr)oxides in layered precursors with no detectable Ni sorbed at layer vacancy sites or structurally incorporated. Despite the high content (~1/3) of Jahn-Teller distorted Mn(III) octahedra in these layered precursors, which is known to be favorable to their conversion to tectomanganates, polymerization of Ni(OH) 2 in phyllomanganate interlayers is kinetically favored during reflux process. Asbolane, a phyllomanganate with an incompleteisland-likeoctahedral layer of metal (hydr)oxides, is thus formed rather than todorokite, a common tectomanganate with a uniform 3×3 tunnel structure. A nitric acid treatment, aiming at the dissolution of the island-like interlayer Ni(OH) 2 layer, allows an easy and unambiguous differentiation between asbolane and todorokite, which is unaffected by the treatment. Both compounds exhibit indeed similar periodicities and can be confused when using X-ray diffraction, despite contrasting intensity ratios. Ni(OH) 2 polymerization hampers the formation of tectomanganates and likely contributes to the prevalence of phyllomanganates over tectomanganates in natural environments. Most Ni is retained during the reflux process, part of Ni (~20%) being likely structurally incorporated in the reaction products, thus enhancing the sequestration of Ni in Mn oxides.