Metal sulfides are promising alternatives to noble metal electrocatalysts for water‐based hydrogen evolution. Pentlandites, notably, exhibit high activity in acidic environments. To explore their potential in alkaline conditions, pentlandite electrodes are tested in both conventional three‐electrode setups and scaled up to a 12.6 cm membrane electrode assembly (MEA). Optimized pentlandites with a stochiometry of , containing Fe, Ni, and Co, show reduced overpotentials for hydrogen evolution with higher Fe and Ni contents. However, a minimum Co content of three equivalents is necessary for peak hydrogen evolution reaction activity with −0.40 V versus reversible hydrogen electrode at −300 mA cm. Stability assessments via X‐ray photoelectron and Raman spectroscopy reveal minor surface changes for Fe and Ni species but significant leaching of cobalt from CoNiS surfaces postelectrolysis. Selected pentlandite catalysts are integrated into MEAs, with achieving 1 A cm at 2.2 V with minimal potential decay of 50 μV h alongside a LaSrCoO anode. These findings underscore the suitability of pentlandite catalysts for water splitting at industrial scales under alkaline conditions.