Trends in Automatic Individual Tree Crown Detection and Delineation—Evolution of LiDAR Data

Abstract

Automated individual tree crown detection and delineation (ITCD) using remotely sensed data plays an increasingly significant role in efficiently, accurately, and completely monitoring forests. This paper reviews trends in ITCD research from 1990-2015 from several perspectives-data/forest type, method applied, accuracy assessment and research objective-with a focus on studies using LiDAR data. This review shows that active sources are becoming more prominent in ITCD studies. Studies using active data-LiDAR in particular-accounted for 80% of the total increase over the entire time period, those using passive data or fusion of passive and active data comprised relatively small proportions of the total increase (8% and 12%, respectively). Additionally, ITCD research has moved from incremental adaptations of algorithms developed for passive data sources to innovative approaches that take advantage of the novel characteristics of active datasets like LiDAR. These improvements make it possible to explore more complex forest conditions (e.g., closed hardwood forests, suburban/urban forests) rather than a single forest type although most published ITCD studies still focused on closed softwood (41%) or mixed forest (22%). Approximately one-third of studies applied individual tree level (30%) assessment, with only a quarter reporting more comprehensive multi-level assessment (23%). Almost one-third of studies (32%) that concentrated on forest parameter estimation based on ITCD results had no ITCD-specific evaluation. Comparison of methods continues to be complicated by both choice of reference data and assessment metric; it is imperative to establish a standardized two-level assessment framework to evaluate and compare ITCD algorithms in order to provide specific recommendations about suitable applications of particular algorithms. However, the evolution of active remotely sensed data and novel platforms implies that automated ITCD will continue to be a promising technology and an attractive research topic for both the forestry and remote sensing communities.

Detection of Citrus Trees From Uav DSMS

“…Another recent review article focussing on the trends in individual tree detection and delineation with LiDAR data was published in (Zhen et al, 2016). Besides active data, imagebased approaches still form another important research area of tree detection studies (e.g.…”

Automatic Discovery and Geotagging of Objects from Street View Imagery

“…Methods proposed in [22,23] target the inverse problem to the one addressed in this work: the street view camera position is inferred from access to geolocations of stationary objects. Much work has been done on monitoring and mapping from mobile LiDAR [24][25][26] and unmanned aerial vehicle (drones) [27,28]. These sensor modalities allow a more complete exploration of scenes and objects therein but are much less widely available than street view imagery.…”

A Region-Based Hierarchical Cross-Section Analysis for Individual Tree Crown Delineation Using ALS Data

“…Based on some existing accuracy assessment methods (e.g., [13,52]), an evaluation system was proposed to comprehensively assess the accuracy of ITCD studies. The accuracy assessment scheme started with individual tree crowns matching between delineated and reference crowns, then quantitative assessment metrics were calculated on the basis of matched crowns.…”

“…Traditionally, forest parameters at the individual tree level have been measured by means of field surveys [11], which are time consuming and cost-intensive when carried out over broad areas [12,13]. Since the early 1960s, with the extensive application of remote sensing data in forest inventory [14][15][16] a variety of image processing techniques were developed for automatically detecting and delineating structure of tree crowns are not always regular and cannot be represented by a simple 2-D filtering window.…”