Treatment with Intravenous Immunoglobulin Does Not Prevent Chronic Immune Thrombocytopenia in Children: Results of a Randomized Controlled Trial

Abstract

Background and objectives: Management in children with newly diagnosed immune thrombocytopenia (ITP) consists of careful observation or treatment with corticosteroids or intravenous immunoglobulin (IVIg). Observational studies suggest a lower risk of chronic ITP in children treated with IVIg. Based on these findings, we designed the multicenter randomized 'Treatment with or without IVIg for Kids with ITP' (TIKI) trial (NTR study ID TC1563) . Primary endpoint was the development of chronic ITP. Secondary objectives were evaluating recovery and response rates as well as identifying predictors of response and recovery. Patients and methods: Children aged 3 months-16 years with newly diagnosed ITP, platelet counts ≤20 x 109/L and mild to moderate bleeding were included in 48 hospitals. Within 72 hours after diagnosis patients were randomized to receive either a single infusion of 0.8 g/kg IVIg or careful observation and treatment only in case of severe bleeding. Clinical data were collected and laboratory studies were performed at diagnosis, after one week, one month, three, six and twelve months. Results: Between May 2009 and May 2015, 200 patients were enrolled, 109 males and 91 females. After randomization, 100 received IVIg and 100 received careful observation. No statistically significant differences regarding baseline characteristics were found between the IVIg and observation group. No statistically significant differences were seen regarding development of chronic ITP (currently defined as a platelet count <100 x 109/L at 12 months) between both groups: 10.2% in the IVIg group en 10.4% in the observation group. The rate of chronic ITP was equal in different age groups: <1 year, 1-10 years, > 10 years. Complete recovery, defined as a platelet count ≥ 100 x 109/L, was significantly more often observed in the IVIg group than in the observation group at 1 week, 1 month and 3 months after diagnosis. Complete response to IVIg at 1 week was seen in 68.7%. No clinical or laboratory predictors of complete response to IVIg were found. Predictors for complete recovery at 12 months were younger age (p=0.03), shorter duration of symptoms prior to diagnosis (p<0.001), mucosal bleeding at diagnosis (p=0.038), higher leukocyte count at diagnosis (p=0.044) and a higher lymphocyte count at diagnosis (p=0.018). In patients randomized to the IVIg group, absence of complete response to IVIg at one week was associated with development of chronic ITP: 20.7% chronic ITP in patients without complete response versus 5.9% in complete responders (p=0.028). Eight patients in the observation group needed rescue treatment (IVIg, methylprednisolone) because of grade 4-5 bleeding, versus one patient in the IVIg group. Seven out of 9 bleeding events occurred within the first month after diagnosis. All 9 patients recovered completely and fast from their bleeding events. Conclusion: In this phase 3 multicenter randomized controlled trial evaluating the efficacy of IVIg treatment versus careful observation in children aged 3 months -16 years with newly diagnosed ITP, the primary end point - the rate of chronic ITP- did not differ significantly between both groups. However, in the IVIg group recovery rates were higher during the first three months after diagnosis and bleeding events occurred less frequently than in the observation group. These results suggest that treatment with IVIg solely to prevent a chronic course of the disease is not justified, but that treatment with IVIg might be beneficial in order to provide adequate hemostasis in selected patient groups. Disclosures Porcelijn: Sanquin: Employment.

Management of newly diagnosed immune thrombocytopenia: can we change outcomes?

“…The preliminary results, presented in abstract form at the 2016 ASH annual meeting, indicated no difference in the rates of persistent disease at 6 months between the two groups (10.2% in the IVIg group and 10.4% in the observation group). 42 The study did show a lower incidence of grade 4 or 5 bleeding in IVIg group compared with placebo (8% vs 1%); however, given the low rates of bleeding, the number needed to treat does not justify exposure of all children to IVIg. There have been no additional randomized trials in pediatric ITP with a primary aim of preventing chronic disease.…”

The Outcome of Withholding Pharmacologic Treatment in Children with Acute ITP

“…Around 20 % of patients still have chronic ITP whether given treatment or not, Chronic ITP is defined as low platelet count for additional one year from appearance [1,11,[20][21][22]. Chronicity is amplified with medications particularly methylprednisolone and immunoglobulin [23] Life-frightening bleed did not happen in the first 6 months after identification [24]. What is known?…”

“…Further tests included ANA, feces for H. Pylori Antigen, HBsAg, HCV and HIV antibodies were performed when needed and totally they were were negative. Antibodies against platelets test didnot done as it is not crucial for diagnosis [17,22,23]. Fundoscopy was done when indicated and luckily was normal.…”