Treatment of depression in the first primary care consultation: A qualitative study

Abstract

Introduction: The first primary care consultation for patients with depression can have long-term consequences for patients, but little is known about treatment decisions at this visit. The aim of this study was to explore the treatment of patients presenting in primary care with a new episode of depression and the drivers behind GPs’ treatment decisions at the initial consultation. Materials and Methods: A random sample of GPs in Auckland was invited to participate. A qualitative study was undertaken using semi-structured interviews. Interview transcripts were analyzed using a general inductive approach. Results: Twenty-one GPs were interviewed. We identified three themes as drivers of treatment decisions at the first visit: characteristics of GPs, characteristics of patients, and characteristics of treatment options. Drivers for prescribing were severe depression and time constraints. A driver for non-pharmacological treatment was a strong doctor–patient relationship. Limited time, skill, and training were associated with low confidence using talking therapies. Access to counseling was reported as poor. There was a very wide range of approaches taken. GPs described preferring antidepressants less and talking therapies more with Māori patients. Behavioral activation was used least despite its ease of use and it being one of the most effective treatments for depression. Conclusion: Treatment of depression at the first visit varies widely between practitioners. GPs report multiple barriers to the provision of talking therapies. A move to a more standardized approach may lead to more equitable care. This is the first study to report findings about the initial primary care consultation for depression.

A Statistical Analysis of Depression

“…Changing to a more standardized direction will bring about more equitable medical services. This is the first report of the initial treatment recommendations for depression [1][2][3][4][5][6][7][8][9][10].…”

Antidepressants in primary care: limited value at the first visit

“…Antidepressants in primary care: limited value at the first visit When patients with a depressive condition first visit a general practitioner, they often get the prescription of an antidepressant 1 . We think that it is better to prescribe medication at a later stage, if at all.…”