Traveling monastic paths: Mobility and religion at medieval Irish monasteries

Alonzi, Elise; Daly, Niamh; Gordon, Gwyneth W.; Scott, Rachel; Knudson, Kelly J.

doi:10.1016/j.jaa.2019.101077

Cited by 6 publications

(4 citation statements)

References 62 publications

Supporting

Mentioning

Contrasting

Order By: Relevance

“…We confirmed the biogenicity of hydroxyapatite using Ca/P (following Alonzi et al, 2019;Simpson et al, 2023). We scanned the surface of each tooth using a Bruker Tracer 5i handheld x-ray fluorescence spectrometer and determined that all three specimens yielded Ca/P within the range expected for biogenic hydroxyapatite (1.3-2.3).…”

Section: Methodsmentioning

confidence: 87%

“…Ashing bones or teeth at a high temperature is an alternative approach for removing organic material that is widely used by strontium isotope researchers. However, published temperatures and times for ashing vary from 500 to 825 °C and 8-12 h (e.g., Sealy et al, 1991;Grupe et al, 1997;Price et al, 2000;Alonzi et al, 2019). Some researchers have raised concerns about the higher temperatures leading to sample recrystallization, which could integrate exogenous material into the enamel's crystal lattice (e.g., Sillen and Sealy, 1995).…”

Section: Frontiers In Environmental Chemistrymentioning

confidence: 99%

See 1 more Smart Citation

Comparison of powdered enamel sample pretreatment methods for strontium isotope analysis

Crowley

Simpson²,

Hammer³

et al. 2023

Front. Environ. Chem.

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Most researchers assume minimal impact of pretreatment on strontium isotope ratios (87Sr/86Sr) for bones and teeth, and methods vary tremendously. We compared 14 pretreatment methods, including no prep other than powdering enamel, ashing, soaking in water, an oxidizing agent (bleach or hydrogen peroxide) or acetic acid (0.1 M, 1.0 M, and 1.0 M buffered with calcium acetate), and a combination of these steps. We prepared and analyzed aliquots of powdered molar enamel from three proboscideans (one modern captive Indian elephant, Elephas maximus indicus; one Pleistocene mastodon, Mammut americanum; and one Miocene gomphothere, Afrochoerodon kisumuensis). Each pretreatment was performed in triplicate and we measured 87Sr/86Sr, Sr concentration, and uranium (U) concentration, using the same lab space and instrumentation for all samples. Variability in 87Sr/86Sr and Sr and U concentrations was considerable across pretreatments. Mean 87Sr/86Sr across methods ranged from 0.70999 to 0.71029 for the modern tooth, 0.71458 to 0.71502 for the Pleistocene tooth, and 0.70804 to 0.70817 for the Miocene tooth. The modern tooth contained the least Sr and negligible U. The Pleistocene tooth contained slightly more Sr and measurable amounts of U, and the Miocene tooth had approximately 5x more Sr and U than the Pleistocene tooth. For all three teeth, variance in 87Sr/86Sr, Sr concentrations, and U concentrations among replicates was statistically indistinguishable across pretreatments, but there were apparent differences among pretreatments for the modern and Pleistocene teeth. Both contained relatively little Sr, and it is possible that small amounts of exogenous Sr from reagents, building materials or dust affected some replicates for some pretreatments. For the modern tooth, median 87Sr/86Sr varied considerably (but statistically insignificantly) across pretreatments. For the Pleistocene tooth, variability in median 87Sr/86Sr was also considerable; some pretreatments were statistically distinct but there were no obvious patterns among methods. For the Miocene tooth, variability in median 87Sr/86Sr was much smaller, but there were significant differences among pretreatments. Most pretreatments yielded 87Sr/86Sr and Sr concentrations comparable to, or lower than, untreated powder, suggesting selective removal of exogenous material with high 87Sr/86Sr. Further evaluation of the mechanisms driving isotopic variability both within and among pretreatment methods is warranted. Researchers should clearly report their methods and avoid combining data obtained using different methods. Small differences in 87Sr/86Sr could impact data interpretations, especially in areas where isotopic variability is low.

show abstract

Section: Methodsmentioning

confidence: 87%

Section: Frontiers In Environmental Chemistrymentioning

confidence: 99%

Comparison of powdered enamel sample pretreatment methods for strontium isotope analysis

Crowley

Simpson²,

Hammer³

et al. 2023

Front. Environ. Chem.

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

show abstract

“…These elements, which substitute for other elements in bioapatite, are only incorporated in enamel and bones in relatively small concentrations during life from diet and drinking water. However, they can be considerably more concentrated in archeological and paleontological specimens due to the replacement of biogenic material and the infilling of voids after the loss of organics (Alonzi et al, 2019). In some cases, researchers compare the elemental composition of a specimen to the surrounding sediment or rock.…”

Section: Background Diagenetic Alteration and Methods Of Detectionmentioning

confidence: 99%

“…Lastly, sometimes researchers use the δ 13 C or δ 18 O values of the specimens themselves to gauge if diagenetic alteration has occurred. The isotopic composition may be altered to reflect post-burial conditions (Zazzo et al, 2004b;Liu et al, 2008;Alonzi et al, 2019). In particular, extremely homogenous δ 13 C and δ 18 O values, or specimens with abnormally high or low isotope values, may be cause for concern (e.g., Koch et al, 1997;Sharp et al, 2000;Zazzo et al, 2004a).…”

Section: Background Diagenetic Alteration and Methods Of Detectionmentioning

confidence: 99%

Is the damage worth it? Testing handheld XRF as a non-destructive analytical tool for determining biogenic bone and tooth chemistry prior to destructive analyses

Simpson

Crowley²,

Sturmer³

2023

Front. Environ. Archaeol.

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Isotopic analysis is destructive and requires that a specimen retains its original (biogenic) chemical composition. A specimen's relative abundance of calcium and phosphorous (Ca/P) or carbonate and phosphate (CO3/PO4) is often used to assess preservation. If a specimen's Ca/P or CO3/PO4 is similar to modern specimens, a specimen's isotopic composition may be biogenic. However, most methods for measuring these proxies are destructive. Moreover the relationships between Ca/P, CO3/PO4 and isotopic preservation are poorly established. In this study, we assessed the ability of handheld X-ray fluorescence (hXRF) to non-destructively evaluate a specimen's preservation by characterizing the calcium to phosphorous ratio (Ca/P). We first established that surface Ca/P (Ca/Psurface) for modern specimens was consistent with expectations for unaltered bone (1.3–2.3). Several specimens had slightly larger ratios, suggesting the currently accepted range may need to be expanded. Second, we tested the ability of Ca/Psurface to detect alteration using twenty Quaternary mammal teeth from Big Bone Lick, Kentucky. Ten specimens had Ca/Psurface between 1.3 and 2.3 and ten had larger ratios, suggesting alteration. Because most methods measure Ca/P in powder (Ca/Ppowder), we compared Ca/Psurface, Ca/Ppowder, and the enamel subsurface (Ca/Psubsurface). With two exceptions, Ca/Psubsurface and Ca/Ppowder were below 2.3, regardless of Ca/Psurface, suggesting that Ca/Ppowder and Ca/Psubsurface underestimate alteration. We next compared Ca/Psurface, CO3/PO4, and carbon (δ13C) and oxygen (δ18O) isotope values for the fossil teeth. Fourteen specimens were identified as altered or unaltered by both proxies, but six specimens only had one altered proxy. Specimens with both proxies altered had lower, less variable δ13C values than specimens with both proxies unaltered. Median δ18O values were similar between these groups. Individuals with altered Ca/Psurface but unaltered CO3/PO4 isotopically resembled specimens with both proxies altered. Conversely, specimens with unaltered Ca/Psurface and altered CO3/PO4 were similar to specimens with both proxies unaltered. Notably, all individuals with both proxies altered had relatively low δ13C values, including a horse and mammoth, which are normally considered grazers (and therefore should have higher δ13C values). These and other altered specimens may be isotopically compromised. Overall, our results suggest that Ca/Psurface is effective at detecting alteration non-destructively, quickly, and affordably, making it an attractive approach for analyzing unique specimens.

show abstract

Investigating pre-Hispanic scarlet macaw origins through radiogenic strontium isotope analysis at Paquimé in Chihuahua, Mexico

Schwartz

Somerville

Nelson

et al. 2021

Journal of Anthropological Archaeology

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Traveling monastic paths: Mobility and religion at medieval Irish monasteries

Cited by 6 publications

References 62 publications

Comparison of powdered enamel sample pretreatment methods for strontium isotope analysis

Comparison of powdered enamel sample pretreatment methods for strontium isotope analysis

Is the damage worth it? Testing handheld XRF as a non-destructive analytical tool for determining biogenic bone and tooth chemistry prior to destructive analyses

Investigating pre-Hispanic scarlet macaw origins through radiogenic strontium isotope analysis at Paquimé in Chihuahua, Mexico

Contact Info

Product

Resources

About