Transtheoretical Model‐Chronic Disease Care for Obesity in Primary Care: A Randomized Trial

Abstract

Objective: To compare health benefits achieved in a transtheoretical model‐chronic disease (TM‐CD) minimal intervention for obesity vs. augmented usual care (AUC). Research Method and Procedures: This was a 2‐year, randomized clinical trial with overweight or obese men and women from 15 primary care sites. AUC (n = 336) included dietary and exercise advice, prescriptions, and three 24‐hour dietary recalls every 6 months. TM‐CD care (n = 329) included AUC elements plus “stage of change” (SOC) assessments for five target behaviors every other month, mailed SOC and target behavior—matched workbooks, and monthly telephone calls from a weight‐loss advisor. Weight change was the primary outcome. Results: Repeated measures models under the missing at random assumption yielded nonsignificant adjusted differences between the AUC and TM‐CD groups for weight change, waist circumference, energy intake or expenditure, blood pressure, and blood lipids. The pattern of change over time suggested that TM‐CD participants were trying harder to impact target behaviors during the first 6 to 12 months of the trial but relapsed afterward. Sixty percent of trial participants maintained their baseline weights for 18 to 24 months. Discussion: A combination of mailed patient materials and monthly telephone calls based on the transtheoretical model and some elements of chronic disease care is not powerful enough, relative to AUC, to alter target behaviors among overweight primary care patients in an obesogenic environment. AUC may be sufficient to maintain weights among at‐risk primary care patients.

Facilitating Partner Support for Lifestyle Change Among Adults with Serious Mental Illness: A Feasibility Pilot Study

“…An average score was calculated for each domain. This measure has been used to assess stage of change among overweight and obese individuals treated for chronic disease in a clinical trial (Logue et al 2005).…”

Treatment of Obesity in Primary Care Practice in the United States: A Systematic Review

“…26,27 Four other trials were moderate intensity (i.e., monthly contact), [28][29][30][31] and the remaining four studies were low intensity. [32][33][34][35] In the active treatment arms of the high-, medium-, and low-intensity studies, the mean number of treatment contacts was 17 (over 7.5 months), 14.8 (over 13.5 months), and 7.2 (over 16 months), respectively.…”

“…[26][27][28][29][30][31]33,34 High attrition (≥35%) was observed in several studies and in two trials 26,27 was not accounted for by the use of intention-to-treat analysis (in which the baseline weight or last observed weight was carried forward for dropouts). ; all were female, and most were African-American.…”

Eating behavior toward oil and fat consumption versus dietary fat intake

“…Such changes improved participants' serum lipid levels and blood pressure 10 . Additionally, participants advanced in stages, such that most individuals were in the action and maintenance stages at the end of the study 7 .…”

“…It is then possible to determine and implement the most effective actions, improving the results of the proposed behavior changes [7][8][9][10] .…”