Transnational Advocacy Without Northern NGO Partners: Vietnamese NGOs in the HIV/AIDS Sector

Abstract

Existing scholarship on transnational advocacy can give the impression that low- and middle-income country (“Southern”) nongovernmental organizations (NGOs) require high-income country (“Northern”) NGO partners to effectively engage actors outside their own state. However, Vietnamese NGOs (VNGOs) have had significant success in their efforts to change the policies and practices of bilateral and multilateral actors toward Vietnam without significant Northern NGO partnership. This article asks how VNGOs have achieved such influence and whether their advocacy effectiveness is likely to be mirrored elsewhere. Drawing on a novel case study of VNGOs in the HIV/AIDS sector, it finds that expertise, credibility, and high organizational capacity have allowed VNGOs to successfully adopt Northern NGOs’ insider lobbying strategies and implement them independently. While the development of VNGO capacity has been accelerated by the unusual legal environment in Vietnam, we predict that as Southern NGO capacity increases elsewhere, reliance on Northern partners will decrease.

The Challenges of Civil Society Organisations: NGO-isation of Resistance in Malaysia?

“…Hence the term "briefcase NGOs" refers to individuals who hold briefcases containing proposal papers and get funding -but in the absence of any clear programme. These funds are obtained from various sources within and outside the country such as philanthropists, government, corporates, institutions, and other NGOs (Pallas & Nguyen, 2018). Thus, fund recipients become representatives to implement the funder's agenda in their respective communities.…”

Understanding National Nonprofit Data Environments

“…Authoritarian governments may use information reporting against organizations (Dupuy et al, 2016; Scott, 1998), as organizations in some issue areas (human rights and education) are then forced to close (Bush, 2018; Heiss & Kelley, 2017). Recent research has shown that authoritarian regimes use foreign financing restrictions to crack down on their civil societies (Dupuy & Prakash, 2020) while increasing their support for local organizations (Pallas & Ngyuen, 2018). In democratic states, the collection of NPO data can be easily incorporated into the preexisting system of taxation and corporate registration due to generally high levels of state capacity to extract and manage data (Bäck & Hadenius 2008).…”

The Hidden Contributions of Local Staff When Hosting International Development Volunteers

“…Vietnam is a culturally and historically complex society. Organizations-including NGOs (Pallas & Nguyen, 2018)-have a record of blending local traditions with foreign practices built on remnants of influence from Confucianism (via China), colonialism (France), socialism (Soviet Union), and, most recently, Western capitalism (Zhu & Verstraetan, 2013); consequently, frameworks positing nationallevel values and norms (e.g., Hofstede, 2010) must be applied with caution (Tuan & Napier, 2000). Nonetheless, several cultural traits believed to affect organizational behaviors are worth highlighting here because of their relevance to my analysis, and because respondents referred to these during interviews.…”