The importance of sexual dimorphism has been highlighted in recent years since the National Institutes of Health’s mandate on considering sex as a biological variable. While recent studies have taken strides to study both sexes side by side, investigations into the normal physiological differences between males and females are limited. In this study, we aimed to characterized sex-dependent differences in glucose metabolism and pancreatic beta cell physiology in normal conditions using C57BL/6J mice, the most common mouse strain used in metabolic studies. Here we report that female mice have improved glucose and insulin tolerance associated with lower non-fasted blood glucose and insulin levels compared to male mice at 3 and 6 month of age. Both male and female animals show beta cell mass expansion from e17.5 to adulthood, and no sex differences were observed at e17.5, newborn, 1 month, or 3 months of age. However, 6-month old males displayed increased beta cell mass in response to insulin resistance compared to littermate females. Molecularly, we uncovered sexual dimorphic alterations in the protein levels of nutrient sensing proteins Ogt and mTOR, as well as differences in glucose-stimulus coupling mechanisms that may underlie the differences in sexually dimorphic beta cell physiology observed in C57BL/6J mice.