Transitioning to virtual ambulatory care during the COVID-19 pandemic: a qualitative study of faculty and resident physician perspectives

Abstract

Background: The COVID-19 pandemic resulted in a rapid shift from in-person to virtual care delivery for many medical specialties across Canada. The purpose of this study was to explore the lived experiences of resident physicians and faculty related to teaching, learning and assessment during ambulatory virtual care encounters within the competency-based medical education model. Methods: In this qualitative phenomenological study, we recruited resident physicians (postgraduate year [PGY] 1–5 trainees) and faculty from the Departments of Surgery and Medicine at Queen’s University, Ontario, via purposive sampling. Participants were not required to have exposure to virtual care. Interviews were conducted from September 2020 to March 2021 by 1 researcher, and 2 researchers conducted focus groups via Zoom to explore participants’ experiences with the transition to virtual care. These were audio-recorded and transcribed verbatim; qualitative data were analyzed thematically. Results: There were 18 male and 19 female participants; 20 were resident physicians and 17 were faculty; 19 were from the Department of Surgery and 18 from the Department of Medicine. All faculty participants had participated in virtual care during ambulatory care; 2 PGY-1 residents in surgery had not actively participated in virtual care, although they had participated in clinics where faculty were using virtual care. The mean age of faculty participants was 38 (standard deviation [SD] 8.6) years, and the mean age of resident physicians was 29 (SD 5.4) years. Overall, 28 interviews and 4 focus groups (range 2–3 participants per group) were conducted, and 4 themes emerged: teaching and learning, assessment, logistical considerations, and suggestions. Barriers to teaching included the lack of direct observations and teaching time, and barriers to assessment included an absence of specific Entrustable Professional Activities (EPAs) and feedback focused on virtual care–related competencies. Logistical challenges included lack of technological infrastructure, insufficient private office space and administrative burdens. Both resident physicians and faculty did not foresee virtual care limiting resident physicians’ ability to progress within competency-based medical education. Benefits of virtual care included increased accessibility to patients for follow-up visits, for disclosing patients’ results and for out-of-town visits. Suggestions included faculty development, improved access to technology and space, educational guidelines for conducting virtual care encounters, and development of virtual care–specific competencies and EPAs. Interpretation: In the postgraduate program we studied, virtual care imposed substantial barriers on teaching, learning and assessment during the first year of the COVID-19 pandemic. Adapting to new circumstances such as virtual care with suggestions from resident physicians and faculty may help to ensure the continuity of...

Analysis of Effect of Six Sigma Method Combined with CI Strategy on Improving of Nursing Quality in Outpatient Infusion Rooms

“…The goal in this study was to improve patient satisfaction with nursing, and the motivation of nursing staff was improved by linking quality of nursing to salary performance after clarifying the goals of nursing management [30]. (3) The CI strategy implements planning and management of the nursing staff's external appearance and internal temperament, making it easier for patients to accept the nursing staff and follow their advice. An increase in nursing satisfaction increases patients' trust in nursing staff and improves their compliance with nursing operations, so patients and their families show increased performance in support of nursing.…”

“…Surveys have shown that in tertiary hospitals, the average daily outpatient infusion room receives more than about 300 patients alone. With the addition of patients' accompanying persons or family members, the average daily population flow in the infusion room is basically at 500-800 visits/day [ 3 ]. At the same time, patients are characterized by limited mobility, organic discomfort, and emotional agitation during infusion.…”

Analysis of the Effect of the Communication Ability of Nurses in Outpatient Infusion Room on the Treatment Experience of Patients and Their Families

“…Compared to patients in the inpatient department, the length of stay (LOS) of patients in the outpatient infusion rooms is generally shorter, and they are more mobile [ 2 ]. The department, however, accommodates a large number of patients and their families, and there are obvious problems such as noisy environment and high crowd density [ 3 ]. The survey shows that in tertiary hospitals, the average daily outpatient infusion room receives more than about 300 patients.…”

Experiences of family and community care physicians and nurse residents in Madrid regarding their training during the COVID-19 pandemic: A Photovoice study

“…Additionally, this change led, similar to what has been described in other studies, to a limitation or disappearance of physical examinations, substantially reducing the capacity for learning and teaching. Similarly, the time constraints imposed by virtual modalities translated into fewer teaching moments for residents [57]. This wasworsened by the fact that the patient pro le primarily consisted of respiratory cases infected with COVID-19, as described in the "COVID-19 Monograph" category, which limited their learning opportunities.…”