Transforming Patient Compliance Research in an Era of Biomedicalization

Abstract

The term patient noncompliance emerged in the 1970s as a tool for analyzing why people do not follow medical directives. Despite its early popularity, the term has languished in sociology while flourishing in biomedical arenas. It seems flaccid in a contemporary healthcare context as it overestimates physician authority and is tone-deaf to biomedicalization. I draw from sociological and anthropological traditions, as well as qualitative interviews with terminally ill patients ( N = 26) and their caregivers ( N = 16), to consider facets of a biomedicalized health experience and implications for an updated vision of compliance. First, pathways to care have proliferated under biomedicalization. With increased pathways comes increased need for understanding how treatment plans are socially constituted and assessed. Finally, increased complexity demands a more diverse vocabulary for understanding health related decisions. This paper is a call to sociologists to take the lead in transforming and updating this consequential concept.

Digital Pathways to Positive Health Perceptions: Does Age Moderate the Relationship Between Medical Satisfaction and Positive Health Perceptions Among Middle-Aged and Older Internet Users?

“…Yet, e-health information consumerism exerted an indirect effect through medical satisfaction. The pre-1980 context of medical culture was characterized by heightened physician authority and the patient’s obligation to comply with the medical advice and treatment prescribed by the physician; a patient was not to pick and choose a treatment nor act like a consumer selecting a treatment according to personal preference (Spencer, 2018). This socialization of the older generation of adults into the sick role, which taught people to be reliant on doctors and not to exercise autonomy in managing personal health, can help us to better understand this differential result in the older adult sample compared with the full sample, which included middle-aged respondents (Kahana & Kahana, 2003; Parsons, 1975).…”

Healthcare Work in Marriage: How Gay, Lesbian, and Heterosexual Spouses Encourage and Coerce Medical Care

“…The US healthcare system relies on individuals to monitor their health status, recognize when a physical health symptom requires medical attention, and seek appropriate medical care (Thompson 2007). Because individuals are embedded in families, this responsibility extends to family members, including spouses (Spencer 2018). As individuals approach midlife, spouses become increasingly likely to take up this responsibility due to the onset of physical illness and recommended health screenings.…”

Discursive strategies for addressing patients’ disalignment with diagnosis in online medical consultations in China

“…When it comes to studying disalignment, associated with dominance and power, understanding local context is of fundamental importance (Spencer, 2018). The importance of understanding context or local sites when interpreting medical interactions has also been underscored (see Timmermans and Almeling, 2009; Wilce, 2009).…”