Transdisciplinarity as an Inference Technique to Achieve a Better Understanding in the Health and Environmental Sciences

Abstract

The problems of the world are not categorised into disciplines. They are far more complex, a reality that the tradition of transdisciplinary research has recognised. When faced with questions in public health and sustainability, the traditional scientific paradigm often seems inadequate, and, at least in medicine, transdisciplinary research has not yet been fully appreciated or acknowledged. This lack of recognition may be partly caused by a lack of cooperation between disciplines and between science and society. In this paper, I discuss some of the challenges that scientists and policymakers face in public health and environment within a methodological context. I present transdisciplinarity as a modern research tool that should be applied in research in health and the environment and argue that these topics can be approached beyond the inherent obstacle of incommensurability between disciplines. Thus, a small step might be taken in this immense research arena.

Solving Problems in Social–Ecological Systems: Definition, Practice and Barriers of Transdisciplinary Research

“…A key characteristic of adaptive governance is iterative learning that enables humans to cope with uncertainty and change, thus enabling institutions that guide stakeholder collaboration (Folke et al 2005). This is in line with the social learning concept (Leeuwis and Pyburn 2002; Keen et al 2005; Axelsson et al 2013b), as well as with the concepts of inference towards the best explanation or best understanding (Harman 1965; Lipton 2004; Annerstedt 2010). Similarly, sustainability indicators and measurable variables need to be developed in collaboration with stakeholders and decision makers, and parameter values need to be defined as norms or performance targets.…”

“…Rather, these will evolve throughout the continuous work and collaboration between researchers from different scientific disciplines, stakeholder participation, as well as communication and dissemination (e.g., Angelstam et al 2013a). Eventually, if successful, the process will result in joint problem–solution, across sciences, technology, and society (Galliers 2004; Annerstedt 2010). This results in a team approach to problem-solving research that aims for synergy from the phases of problem definition to solutions.…”

A Collaborative Research Exploration of Pollutant Mixtures and Adverse Birth Outcomes by Using Innovative Spatial Data Mining Methods: The DoMiNO Project

“…We have learned that collaboration is an evolving process, which starts from planning and writing the proposal and goes on to the next phases, in which relationship among team members evolve and strengthen over time, through formal and informal activities. The research progresses thanks to the integration of different perspectives, methods and experiences [52,53], and the team's commitment.…”

Sustainable Management of Plant Quarantine Pests: The Case of Olive Quick Decline Syndrome

“…Achieving consensus [110] is an important step in plant health management [8]. While plant disease risk can be assessed by using analytical techniques which consider spatial and temporal disease factors, Mills et al [8] indicate that this technical approach may not provide the best guidelines for policy formulation and decision-making.…”