Training registered nurses to conduct pre-implementation assessment to inform program scale-up: an example from the rural Transitions Nurse Program

Abstract

Objectives Adapting evidence-based practices to local settings is critical for successful implementation and dissemination. A pre-implementation assessment evaluates local context to inform implementation, but there is little published guidance for clinician-implementers. The rural Transitions Nurse Program (TNP) is a care coordination intervention that facilitates care transitions for rural veterans. In year 1 of TNP, pre-implementation assessments were conducted by a centralized project team through multi-day visits at five sites nationwide. In year 2, we tested if local site TNP nurses could conduct pre-implementation assessments using evidence-based tools and coaching from the TNP team. This required developing a multicomponent pre-implementation strategy bundle to guide data collection and synthesis. We hypothesized that (1) nurses would find the pre-implementation assessment useful for tailoring TNP to local contexts and (2) nurses would identify similar barriers and facilitators to those identified at first year sites. Methods The bundle included guides for conducting key informant interviews, brainwriting, process mapping, and reflective journaling. We evaluated TNP nurse satisfaction and perceived utility of the structure and process of the training and bundle through pre-post surveys. To assess the outcome of data collection efforts, we interviewed nurses 4 months after completion of the pre-implementation assessment to determine if and how they used pre-implementation findings to tailor implementation of TNP to local contexts. To further assess outcomes, all data that the nurses collected were analyzed thematically. Themes related to barriers and facilitators were compared across years. Findings Five nurses at different VA medical centers used the pre-implementation strategy bundle to collect site-level data and completed pre-post surveys. Findings indicated that the pre-implementation assessment was highly recommended, and the bundle provided adequate training. Nurses felt that pre-implementation work oriented them to the local context and illustrated how to integrate TNP into existing processes. Barriers and facilitators identified by nurses were similar to those collected in year 1 by the TNP research team, including communication challenges, need for buy-in, and logistical concerns. Conclusions This proof-of-concept study suggests that evidence-based tools can effectively guide clinician-implementers through the process of conducting a pre-implementation assessment. This approach positively informed TNP implementation and oriented nurses to their local context prior to implementation.

Rural caregivers’ preparedness for detecting and responding to the signs of worsening health conditions in recently hospitalised patients at risk for readmission: a qualitative descriptive study

“…For such caregivers, telephone follow-up from a nurse familiar with the patient’s situation may be a viable alternative to home or outpatient follow-up. Prior research has found telephone follow-up on warning signs, as part of a multicomponent postdischarge intervention, to be effective in reducing rural hospital readmissions42 43 and has been successfully implemented by hospital nurses,44 highlighting its potential for wider scalability.…”

Adaptation of the brainwriting premortem technique to inform the co-creation of COVID-19 testing strategies in underserved communities in South San Diego

“…A novel technique that combines these two approaches, brainwriting premortem, builds on a combination of individual wisdom and group problem-solving to identify potential failure points for the implementation of a program and possible solutions for these failure points [ 23 ]. Brainwriting premortem has been used recently in the context of implementation science to inform the refinement of interventions based on input from multiple partners [ 26 – 28 ]. While traditional approaches to the brainwriting premortem include in-person group-based activities, this was not feasible during the early stages of the COVID-19 pandemic for members of underserved communities or frontline healthcare providers due to the increased care demands on families and on providers at clinics.…”

Sustainment stories: a qualitative analysis of barriers to sustainment of the National Rural Transitions of Care Nurse Program

“…Participating VAMCs were provided with information that could be used to support sustainment through audit and feedback, such as site level program outcomes data as well as visual representations of the reach and impact of the program [ 9 ]. TNP was successfully implemented at 11 VAMC’s, and evaluation of the implementation process identified several barriers to implementation, including competing processes, communication challenges across care settings, need for program buy-in, and recognized need for the program [ 10 – 12 ]. Developing a better understanding of how to sustain care coordination intervientions is vital for planning how to best leverage limited resources ensure patients continue to experience high quality transitions of care [ 13 ].…”