Trainee Sex and Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education Milestone Assessments During General Surgery Residency

Abstract

In evaluating the effectiveness of general surgery (GS) training, an unbiased assessment of the progression of residents with attention to individual learner factors is imperative.OBJECTIVE To evaluate the role of trainee sex in milestone achievement over the course of GS residency using national data from the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (ACGME). DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTSThis cross-sectional study evaluated female and male GS residents enrolled in ACGME-accredited programs in the US from 2014 to 2018 with reported variation in milestones performance across years in training and representation. Data were analyzed from November 2019 to June 2021. MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURESMean reported milestone score at initial and final assessment, and predicted time-to-attainment of equivalent performance by sex. RESULTS Among 4476 GS residents from 250 programs who had milestone assessments at any point in their clinical training, 1735 were female (38.8%). Initially, female and male residents received similar mean (SD) milestone scores (1.95 [0.50] vs 1.94 [0.50]; P = .69). At the final assessment, female trainees received overall lower mean milestone scores than male trainees (4.25 vs 4.31; P < .001). Significantly lower mean milestone scores were reported for female residents at the final assessment for several subcompetencies in both univariate and multivariate analyses, with only medical knowledge 1 (pathophysiology, diagnosis, and initial management) common to both. Multilevel mixed-effects linear modeling demonstrated that female trainees had significantly lower rates of monthly milestone attainment in the subcompetency of medical knowledge 1, which was associated with a significant difference in training time of approximately 1.8 months.CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE Both female and male GS trainees achieved the competency scores necessary to transition to independence after residency as measured by the milestones assessment system. Initially, there were no sex differences in milestone score. By graduation, there were differences in the measured assessment of female and male trainees across several subcompetencies. Careful monitoring for sex bias in the evaluation of trainees and scrutiny of the training process is needed to ensure that surgical residency programs support the educational needs of both female and male trainees.

Trainee Physician Milestone Ratings and Patient Complaints in Early Posttraining Practice

“…It is also possible that disparities and potential biases related to gender and race and ethnicity might have affected Milestones ratings and/or patient complaints . In the present study, we found no difference in the proportion rated as below target for the Milestones by gender and no difference in the proportion with patient complaints by gender.…”

A Consensus-Driven Revision of the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education Case Log System: Pediatric Anesthesiology Fellowship Education

“…Any qualitative, global assessment without objective metrics of success is inherently incomplete and may additionally be fraught with racial, gender, and cultural biases. [28][29][30] To the extent that trainees, program directors, and ACGME must, at least in part, rely on objective metrics such as case logs, we believe this revised case log system to be a significant leap forward from its predecessor.…”

Chinese digestive surgery interns’ learning quality and English reading proficiency during COVID-19 pandemic: Comparison between face-to-face versus WeChat teaching and learning

“…It requires medical students to possess advanced medical knowledge and high standard operation skills, often being one of the most difficult clinical trainings for medical students [ 6 ]. Gastrointestinal surgery training helps improve other essential skills for medical students, such as clinical thinking ability, and lays a foundation for further study of other specialties [ 7 ].…”