Trade Liberalization and Regional Dynamics

Abstract

We study the evolution of trade liberalization's effects on Brazilian local labor markets. Regions facing larger tariff cuts experienced prolonged declines in formal sector employment and earnings relative to other regions. The impact of tariff changes on regional earnings 20 years after liberalization was three times the effect after 10 years. These increasing effects on regional earnings are inconsistent with conventional spatial equilibrium models, which predict declining effects due to spatial arbitrage. We investigate potential mechanisms, finding empirical support for a mechanism involving imperfect interregional labor mobility and dynamics in labor demand, driven by slow capital adjustment and agglomeration economies. This mechanism gradually amplifies the effects of liberalization, explaining the slow adjustment path of regional earnings and quantitatively accounting for the magnitude of the long-run effects. (JEL F16, J23, J31, J61, O15, O19, R23)

The 1990s trade and wages debate in retrospect

“…The blinkering of vision by HO theory, with its assumption of costless factor mobility within countries, also had the unfortunate effect of causing economists to forget that the social costs of expansion of trade tend to be concentrated on narrowly defined industries, occupations and—with strong persistence—localities (Autor, Dorn, & Hanson, ; Dix‐Carneiro & Kovak, ). This concentration of effects and associated adjustment costs, long recognised in specific‐factors theory and in the political economy of trade policy, was for example discussed in less than 500 words of the 500‐page Wood (), being sidelined by the simpler—though also important—view of skilled workers as a class gaining at the expense of unskilled workers.…”

The ‘China shock,’ exports and U.S. employment: A global input–output analysis

“… Dix‐Carneiro and Kovak () describe a general model with trade reform and regional labor‐market dynamics. …”

Input tariff liberalisation and servitisation in manufacturing: Evidence from China's WTO accession

“…The benefits of trade liberalisation have long been widely explored in the literature (Brandt et al, 2017;Dix-Carneiro & Kovak, 2017). However, economic globalisation has been increasingly questioned after entering the 21st century.…”