Tracking the evolution of hospice palliative care in Canada: A comparative case study analysis of seven provinces

Abstract

BackgroundAn aging population, rise in chronic illnesses, increase in life expectancy and shift towards care being provided at the community level are trends that are collectively creating an urgency to advance hospice palliative care (HPC) planning and provision in Canada. The purpose of this study was to analyze the evolution of HPC in seven provinces in Canada so as to inform such planning and provision elsewhere. We have endeavoured to undertake this research out of awareness that good future planning for health and social care, such as HPC, typically requires us to first look backwards before moving forward.MethodsTo identify key policy and practice events in HPC in Canada, as well as describe facilitators of and barriers to progress, a qualitative comparative case study design was used. Specifically, the evolution and development of HCP in 7 strategically selected provinces is compared. After choosing the case study provinces, the grey literature was searched to create a preliminary timeline for each that described the evolution of HPC beginning in 1970. Key informants (n = 42) were then interviewed to verify the content of each provincial timeline and to discuss barriers and facilitators to the development of HPC. Upon completion of the primary data collection, a face-to-face meeting of the research team was then held so as to conduct a comparative study analysis that focused on provincial commonalities and differences.ResultsFindings point to the fact that HPC continues to remain at the margins of the health care system. The development of HPC has encountered structural inheritances that have both sped up progress as well as slowed it down. These structural inheritances are: (1) foundational health policies (e.g., the Canada Health Act); (2) service structures and planning (e.g., the dominance of urban-focused initiatives); and (3) health system decisions (e.g., regionalization). As a response to these inheritances, circumventions of the established system of care were taken, often out of necessity. Three kinds of circumventions were identified from the data: (1) interventions to shift the system (e.g., the role of advocacy); (2) service innovations (e.g., educational initiatives); and (3) new alternative structures (e.g., the establishment of independent hospice organizations). Overall, the evolution of HPC across the case study provinces has been markedly slow, but steady and continuous.ConclusionsHPC in Canada remains at the margins of the health care system. Its integration into the primary health care system may ensure dedicated and ongoing funding, enhanced access, quality and service responsiveness. Though demographics are expected to influence HPC demand in Canada, our study confirms that concerned citizens, advocacy organizations and local champions will continue to be the agents of change that make the necessary and lasting impacts on HPC in Canada.

Cultural understanding in the provision of supportive and palliative care: perspectives in relation to an indigenous population

“…Each of the nine district health authorities across Nova Scotia operates a palliative care programme. Their evolution is comparable with that in other Canadian provinces including greater gaps in rural than in urban areas 14. Their extent of services varies as does their linkage to supportive cancer care15 and to the provincial home care programme.…”

A Snapshot of Advance Directives in Long-Term Care: How Often Is "Do Not" Done?

“…While many jurisdictions in Canada have initiatives under way to improve end-of-life services out of hospital, few nursing homes have formal palliative care programs. 1,11 • More data is required in order to follow trends over time. While this analysis provides good baseline information on the use of DNR and DNH directives, data about these directives is no longer captured and reported to CIHI.…”

Supporting and improving community health services—a prospective evaluation of ECHO technology in community palliative care nursing teams

“…Changing demographic trends including an ageing population and an increased life expectancy for individuals living with life-limiting illnesses, in addition to the impact of illness on individuals’ physical, psychological and social well-being, means that the demand for high-quality palliative care services is expected to increase 5. This is accompanied by a shift in palliative care practice to an approach which recognises that patients with progressive chronic diseases other than cancer share common symptoms and challenge.…”