Towards Large-Scale Integrative Taxonomy (LIT): Resolving the Data Conundrum for Dark Taxa

Abstract

New, rapid, accurate, scalable, and cost-effective species discovery and delimitation methods are needed for tackling “dark taxa”, here defined as groups for which <10% of all species are described and the estimated diversity exceeds 1000 species. Species delimitation for these taxa should be based on multiple data sources (“integrative taxonomy”) but collecting multiple types of data risks impeding a discovery process that is already too slow. We here develop Large-scale Integrative Taxonomy (LIT), an explicit method where preliminary species hypotheses are generated based on inexpensive data that can be obtained quickly and cost-effectively. These hypotheses are then evaluated based on a more expensive type of “validation data” that are only obtained for specimens selected based on objective criteria applied to the preliminary species hypotheses. We here use this approach to sort 18 000 scuttle flies (Diptera: Phoridae) into 315 preliminary species hypotheses based on NGS barcode (313 bp) clusters (using Objective Clustering (OC) with a 3% threshold). These clusters are then evaluated with morphology as the validation data. We develop quantitative indicators for predicting which barcode clusters are likely to be incongruent with morphospecies by randomly selecting 100 clusters for in-depth validation with morphology. A linear model demonstrates that the best predictors for incongruence between barcode clusters and morphology are maximum p-distance within the cluster and a newly proposed index that measures cluster stability across different clustering thresholds. A test of these indicators using the 215 remaining clusters reveals that these predictors correctly identify all clusters that are incongruent with morphology. In our study all morphospecies are true or disjoint subsets of the initial barcode clusters so that all incongruence can be eliminated by varying clustering thresholds. This leads to a discussion of when a third data source is needed to resolve incongruent grouping statements. The morphological validation step in our study involved 1039 specimens (5.8% of the total). The formal LIT protocol we propose would only have required the study of 915 (5.1%: 2.5 specimens per species), as we show that clusters without signatures of incongruence can be validated by only studying two specimens representing the most divergent haplotypes. To test the generality of our results across different barcode clustering techniques, we establish that the levels of incongruence are similar across Objective Clustering (OC), Automatic Barcode Gap Discovery (ABGD), Poisson Tree Processes (PTP) and Refined Single Linkage (RESL) (used by Barcode of Life Data System (BOLD) to assign Barcode Index Numbers (BINs)). OC and ABGD achieved a maximum congruence score with morphology of 89% while PTP was slightly less effective (84%). RESL could only be tested for a subset of the specimens because the algorithm is not public. BINs based on 277 of the original 1 714 haplotypes were 86% congruent with morphology while the values were 89% for OC, 74% for PTP, and 72% for ABGD.

Collective and harmonized high throughput barcoding of insular arthropod biodiversity: Toward a Genomic Observatories Network for islands

“…HTS barcoding also opens the door for inclusive inventories that include immature life history stages, and extend to the typically small and cryptic taxa fractions of arthropod diversity that are associated with high levels of undescribed species, the so called "dark taxa" (Hartop et al, 2022;Hausmann et al, 2020). As proof of concept, Yeo They additionally demonstrated the value of barcode reference libraries, even if incomplete, for efficient bioinformatic processing to achieve reliable haplotype data (Andújar et al, 2021) and, in doing so, provided strong evidence for taxonomic inflation in the absence of such processing.…”

Global convergence of dominance and neglect in flying insect diversity

“…However, Malaise traps are so effective that sample processing is a major challenge due to high specimen and species yields 14,17 . In addition, most specimens belong to species that cannot be identified because taxonomic expertise for hyperdiverse taxa is non-existent and/or dwindling for many species-rich clades caught in Malaise traps ("dark taxa") 18 . Fortunately, recent advances in large-scale DNA barcoding with new sequencing technologies allow for processing large numbers of specimens rapidly and cost-effectively 19,20 .…”

Novel molecular resources for single-larva barcoding of enigmatic crustacean y-larvae

“…Increased availability of diverse phylogenomic resources has transformed pancrustacean (Hexapoda and 'Crustacea') systematics, yet numerous clades remain recalcitrant to analysis due to a critical lack of molecular resources (Regier et Bernot et al, 2022). This particularly applies to the so-called 'dark' taxa (Hartop et al, 2022), of which the enigmatic crustacean y-larvae (Pancrustacea: Thecostraca: Facetotecta) constitute one of the most remarkable examples. Y-larvae are fascinating invertebrates that are almost exclusively known from planktonic larval stages (Glenner et al, 2008;Dreyer et al, 2022).…”