Towards Data-Driven Policymaking for the Urban Heat Transition in The Netherlands: Barriers to the Collection and Use of Data

Abstract

The transition of our society towards a sustainable, low-carbon reality is challenging governments at all levels to establish, implement and monitor policies that can realize this transition. In the Netherlands, cities are developing datadriven policies to ensure that the urban environment will make the transition from the use of natural gas to sustainable alternatives. However, the collection and (re-)use of data is not without its challenges, which may hamper policymaking, and thereby the ambitions for the transition. Therefore, this paper explores barriers to the data collection and use for the urban heat transition, based on literature and practice. First, an overview of barriers is derived from literature. Subsequently, we interview policy makers of eight frontrunner cities to explore which barriers they encounter in practice. We find that cities need different data in different phases of the strategy development, and that the main barriers for the collection and re-use of data are the required amount of effort and time, and the experienced difficulties to take decisions based on data that is poor in quality, level of detail and topicality.

Energy democracy: A digital future?

“…New forms of decision-making raise questions about how decisions are held accountable by citizens. For example, the push towards 'datadriven policy making' presents questions as to how data is used and processed; for example which models, statistical techniques or algorithms are employed [86,87]. These new considerations can add complexity to decision-making chains, as well as new challenges to determining where liabilities and responsibilities are held, and by whom.…”

Planning and modelling of local integrated energy systems: Tools and strategies for the (local) renewable energy transition

“…In an assessment of decentralised energy planning models, Yazdanie and Orehounig argue for the relevance of bottom-up approaches and short to medium time horizons, concluding that new models and approaches need to be developed and applied [39]. The authors assert that significant gaps exist in the field of energy system models for municipalities and cities, mentioning factors such as a lack of integrated modelling approaches and data availability; a conclusion which is supported by Diran and Veenstra [40].…”