Towards a Conceptual Framework for Struggles over Democracy in Backsliding States: Gender Equality Policy in Central Eastern Europe

Abstract

Trends of de-democratization across Europe and the Americas are emerging, along with opposition to gender equality and threats to previous gender equality policy gains. Yet de-democratization has been barely analysed through the lens of gender equality, and so far, efforts to systematically analyse the implications for inclusive democracy and the representation of gender interests are lacking. Backsliding in gender policies, and new forms of feminist engagement with hostile states and publics, also raise new challenges to the literature on gender and politics. In this article we explore gender equality policy backsliding in fragile democracies. Backsliding and de-democratization processes in these contexts pose a series of important challenges to how we have thought about gender policy change in progressive, mainly Western democratic contexts until now. We propose a conceptual framework discussing these two conceptually interesting realms: backsliding in gender equality policies, and feminist responses to backsliding. We illustrate our framework with empirical observations from four backsliding or temporarily backsliding Central and Eastern European countries: Croatia, Hungary, Poland and Romania. With our article we aim to contribute to the understanding of gendered aspects of de-democratization both in gender and politics literature and in mainstream democratization literature.

Constructing European Union Identity through LGBT Equality Promotion: Crises and Shifting Othering Processes in the European Union Enlargement

“…Such developments, in which the content of the fundamental values identity of the EU is being reconceptualised and renegotiated (Mos, 2018), combined with the current processes of European disintegration (e.g. Brexit), democratic backsliding (Krizsan and Roggeband, 2018), and the rise of right-wing politics (Kováts and Põim, 2015), raises doubts to how long the EU can continue to rely on LGBT rights to maintain its external symbolic boundaries.…”

Challenging abortion stigma: framing abortion in Ireland and Poland

“…Ireland and Poland also represent sites of resistance for global efforts to undermine reproductive rights across Europe and the United States that include the discursive de-legitimisation of gender equality, dismantling or poor implementation of gender-progressive policies and the underfunding and marginalisation of women’s organisations. 56 , 57 In Poland this opposition to gender equality is explicit and reinforced through party political formations. In Ireland, extreme right-wing populism is less evident, yet “progressive neo-liberalism” 58 maintains elements of social conservatism and traditional gendered norms in both state and society.…”

Is feminism doomed? Feminist praxis in the times of ‘gender ideology’ in Slovakia

“…Since 2011, these phenomena provided fertile ground for the so-called gender ideology rhetoric—that is, conservative attacks on feminist engagement in the governmental and non-governmental sector—(Valkovičová and Maďarová, 2019), and for the subtle democratic backsliding on gender equality policies, understood as a gradual process of ‘going back on previous commitments to gender equality’ (Krizsan and Roggeband, 2018: 92). Over the last several years, we witnessed the adoption of ‘family mainstreaming’ or building of the state-wide infrastructure for ‘family counselling’ by the EU-funded conservative and church-based organizations.…”

“…The advocacy practices are mostly realized by the established feminist organizations which continuously need to reflect on the new context of the discursive delegitimation of gender equality policies and feminist agendas (Krizsan and Roggeband, 2018; Roggeband and Krizsán, 2020). The development around the Council of Europe Convention on preventing and combating violence against women and domestic violence (i.e.…”