There is limited information on the effectiveness of injectable adsorbent suspensions (IASs) for in situ sequestration of perand polyfluoroalkyl substance (PFAS)-contaminated groundwater, especially regarding potential PFAS release in the presence of coexisting anions. In this study, four IASs were injected into water-saturated sand columns. The IAS mobility and retention and the sequestration of 3 perfluoroalkyl sulfonates and 6 perfluoroalkyl carboxylic acids (PFCAs) and their release were investigated, following two designs. The IAS retention (95%) was evaluated by using organic carbon measurements and scanning electron microscopy. The anion exchange resin (A-IXR) IAS facilitated the largest (76 to 99% or 239−291 mg) PFAS sequestration, with the extent of short chain PFAS sequestration affected by competitive effects. Total PFAS released ranged from 11 to 54%, with the A-IXR columns also exhibiting the largest (44% to 52%) release of short chain PFAS (especially PFCA) in simulated groundwater, as influenced by anion exchange. Mass balance of PFAS ranged from 18 to 129%, with the longer chain PFAS showing the lowest recoveries, indicating their stronger sequestration. Overall, a complete picture regarding the effectiveness of IAS for in situ PFAS sequestration must consider the potential release of previously sequestered PFAS, given the influence of the variable groundwater chemistry.