Accessing semiconductor nanocrystals free from surface defects is an outstanding challenge in the design of materials with targeted properties. Despite the established importance of Z-type ligand surface passivation to eliminate defects, the optical and electronic properties of nanocrystals vary depending on the nanocrystal composition and Z-type ligand identity. In this work, a series of Cd-, Zn-, and Pb-based non-native Z-type ligands with the formula MX 2 (X = undecylenate or chloride) were employed to elucidate Z-type ligand characteristics that result in surface passivation of undercoordinated surface ions to eliminate trap states from CdSe nanocrystals. First, CdSe nanocrystals were reacted with N,N,N′,N′-tetramethylethylene-1,2-diamine (TMEDA) to remove native Cd(oleate) 2 Z-type ligands from the surface, resulting in undercoordinated surface chalcogen ions. After subsequent reaction with M(UDA) 2 , ligands bound to the surface were quantified by NMR spectroscopy, and in parallel, the impact of Z-type ligands on the nanocrystal optical properties was monitored using photoluminescence spectroscopy. We find that Cd-and Zn-based Z-type ligands exhibit similar reactivity with the nanocrystal surface via NMR spectroscopy, yet Cd(UDA) 2 passivation results in an 800% PL increase while Zn(UDA) 2 passivation yields a 13% increase in photoluminescence intensity. Nanocrystals reacted with Pb-based Ztype ligands have lower surface coverage, as quantified by NMR spectroscopy, and lead to only a marginal increase of nanocrystal photoluminescence intensity (60%). These data indicate that the metal identity of the Z-type ligand has a profound impact on the reactivity and resulting electronic structure of the postsynthetically modified nanocrystal. This work provides a framework for achieving defect-free CdSe nanocrystals.