Toward a debugging pedagogy: helping students learn to get unstuck with physical computing systems

Abstract

Purpose The purpose of this paper is to examine how a middle school science teacher, new to programming, supports students in learning to debug physical computing systems consisting of programmable sensors and data displays. Design/methodology/approach This case study draws on data collected during an inquiry-oriented instructional unit in which students learn to collect, display and interpret data from their surrounding environment by wiring and programming a physical computing system. Using interaction analysis, the authors analyzed video recordings of one teacher’s (Gabrielle) pedagogical moves as she supported students in debugging their systems as they drew upon a variety of embodied, material and social resources. Findings This study presents Gabrielle’s debugging interactional grammar, highlighting the pedagogical possibilities for supporting students in systematic ways, providing affective support (e.g. showing them care and encouragement) and positioning herself as a learner with the students. Gabrielle’s practice, and therefore her pedagogy, has the potential to support students in becoming better debuggers on their own in the future. Originality/value While much of the prior work on learning to debug focuses on learner actions and possible errors, this case focuses on an educator’s debugging pedagogy centered on the educator debugging with the learners. This case study illustrates the need for educators to exhibit deft facilitation, vulnerability and orchestration skills to support student development of their own process for and agency in debugging.

Welcome to the oops club!: Varied patterns of mistake responses in a veteran teacher’s classroom

“…In subtle micro-level interactions with children, teachers model expected responses to mistakes and convey their values about student performance during instruction. When they prioritize process over product and attend to their students' emotional responses to errors, teachers help to support critical thinking and encourage learners to push through their frustrations (Hennessy Elliott et al, 2023).…”

Is Computational Empowerment Promoted in the Hour of Code? Analyzing Opportunities for Conceptual, Creative, and Critical Engagement in the Design of Introductory Computing Activities

“…As Papert (1980) remarked, "errors benefit us because they lead us to study what happened, to understand what went wrong, and, through understanding, to fix it" (p. 114). However, debugging is also exacting and can be difficult for students to learn and challenging for teachers to teach (McCauley et al, 2008;Hennessy Elliott, 2023). For many students, encountering bugs can generate fear and anxiety that can lead to disengagement and the avoidance of computing (Scott & Ghinea, 2013;Coto et al, 2022).…”