Tooth replacement is a conserved process in vertebrates extending back to the ancesters of modern fish, amphibians, reptiles and mammals. The patterns in dinosaurs and reptiles have been described by scientists as regular waves going from posterior to anterior of the jaws where every other tooth is replaced. The patterns suggest that local and possibly jaw-wide communication betwen tooth families is involved. The tooth replacement process is not well understood since there are few animals with acessible dentitions. In this study we study leopard geckos in which tooth succession occurs repeatedly throughout life thus giving multiple opportunities to track the process. In addition we performed 2 types of experiments that unlaterally interfere with tooth replacement. Animals were followed using serial wax bites for 2-3 months prior to unilateral, selective tooth removal and then for 7-9 months after surgery. The data on tooth presence or absence was transformed mathematically to capture the time between eruption events of the successional tooth at the same position. Relationships between neighbouring tooth families and across the midline were measured to look for relative phase symmetry or asymmetry. We then tested 5 alternative models of tooth replacement to explain the observed patterns of recovery. The selective removal of unerupted second generation teeth showed that there were no signals passing back to the tooth forming field. The pattern of tooth eruption was not only re-established but it was in phase with the surrounding unperturbed tooth locations, as reflected in the nearest-neighbour diagonal lines. In animals that had permanent ablation of the dental lamina, the cycling of teeth anterior and posterior to the gap was unaffected refuting the presence of directional factors that pass from one tooth family to the next. Finally we compared the patterns of replacement between geckos and alligators using Edmund, 1962 data. The general nearest neighbour staggered patterns were conserved but the alligator had very slower rates of replacement in the posterior jaws. The geckos maintain similar cycling frequences across the jaws. In conclusion, we reject the Osborn model of zones of local inhibition and Edmunds wave-stimulus theory.Instead propose that teeth themselves are cycling and that these cycles regulate the staggered timing of tooth initiation. We also showed that once established, the local control of tooth replacement is very resilient to environmental perturbations as long as the dental epithelium is retained.