Too stupid for PhD? Doctoral impostor syndrome among Finnish PhD students

Abstract

Impostor syndrome (IS) refers to the inner speech of self-doubt and the belief that you are not as competent as others perceive you to be. The university can be considered a work environment prone to IS, especially because of the requirements of present higher education and science policy, which emphasizes continuous evaluation, a competitive spirit, and a focus on performance and excellence. It is therefore understandable that many doctoral students have begun to experience inadequacy and uncertainty during their postgraduate studies. This study focuses on the prevalence of IS among Finnish PhD students (n = 1694). In particular, attention is paid to the background factors in which experiences of uncertainty and attitudes related to IS are linked. Theoretically, we interpret IS as a phenomenon related to the habitus formed through an individual’s life experiences and the inner speech associated with it. Based on the results of the linear regression analysis, the lack of encouragement in childhood and a low level of planning when applying for doctoral studies explain the emergence of IS in a statistically significant manner.

Supporting Doctoral Candidates through Completion and Final Examination

“…Perfectionism in academia is not a new concept. Academia is a performance-and metric-driven career path [15] that attracts people who have perfectionistic traits. This is equally true of doctoral candidates [14,16].…”

Guest editorial: Emerging voices in lesson studies

“…Young professionals are also inclined to experience inadequacy and uncertainty during their postgraduate studies. They feel intimidated or anxious to publish their work (Nori and Vanttaja, 2022).…”

The impostor phenomenon among doctoral students: a scoping review

“…The subsequent development of this phenomenon has garnered widespread attention from scholars, who believe that it encompasses a broader range of groups and involves more complex characteristics. Our study draws on the research of Nori and Vanttaja (2022) , and it suggests that IP refers to a mindset in which a person considers themselves less proficient than they actually are. While the people around them might find the person skilled and competent, they themselves think that they only managed to give an impression of their prowess.…”