To portray clonal evolution in blood cancer, count your stem cells

Abstract

Clonal evolution, the process of expansion and diversification of mutated cells, plays an important role in cancer development, resistance and relapse. While clonal evolution is most often conceived of as driven by natural selection, recent studies uncovered that neutral evolution shapes clonal evolution in a significant proportion of solid cancers. In hematological malignancies, the interplay between neutral evolution and natural selection is also disputed. Because natural selection selects cells with a higher fitness-providing a growth advantage to some cells relative to others-the architecture of clonal evolution serves as indirect evidence to distinguish natural selection from neutral evolution and has been associated with different prognoses for the patient. Linear architecture, when the new mutant clone grows within the previous one, is distinctive of hematological malignancies and typically interpreted as driven by natural selection. Here we wish to discuss the role of natural selection and neutral evolution in the production of linear clonal architectures in hematological malignancies. While it is tempting to attribute linear evolution to natural selection, we argue that a lower number of contributing stem cells accompanied by genetic drift can also result in a linear pattern of evolution as illustrated by simulations of clonal evolution in hematopoietic stem cells. The number of stem cells contributing to long-term clonal evolution is not known in the pathological context and we advocate that estimating these numbers in the context of cancer and ageing is crucial to parsing out neutral evolution from natural selection, two processes that require different therapeutic strategies.

Testing Multi-Task Cancer Evolution: How Do We Test Ecological Hypotheses in Cancer?

“…Drift may play a significant role in some cancers' dynamics, limiting variation available for selection. Cancer stem cells may effectively function as genetic "bottlenecks, " governing the variation available for selection in a tumor (Laplane, 2018;Lyne et al, 2020). Such bottlenecks could be limiting the possible scope of evolutionary change in some cancers.…”

Leukemic Stem Cell: A Mini-Review on Clinical Perspectives

“…Neutral evolution of these passenger mutations can also shape clonal evolution, notably by a phenomenon called genetic drift, in which the allele frequencies of a mutation change over time. In addition, when both driver and passenger mutations occur in the same cell, the passenger mutations increase their allele frequency with the driver mutations, which is a phenomenon called hitchhiking that also participate in clonal evolution (47,48).…”

Hematopoiesis during Ontogenesis, Adult Life, and Aging

“…However, these mutations can also take part in clonal evolution, in particular through a phenomenon called genetic drift, in which allele frequencies of the mutation change over time due to mere chance [122]. In addition, when passenger mutations occur in the same cells as the driver's mutations, the passenger mutations increase their allele frequency along with the driver's mutations [123].…”