To ‘Get by’ or ‘get help’? A qualitative study of physicians’ challenges and dilemmas when patients have limited English proficiency

Abstract

ObjectiveEncounters between patients and physicians who do not speak the same language are relatively common in Canada, particularly in urban settings; this trend is increasing worldwide. Language discordance has important effects on health outcomes, including mortality. This study sought to explore physicians’ experiences of care provision in situations of language discordance in depth.DesignQualitative study based on individual interviews. Interview guides elicited physicians’ perspectives on how they determined whether communication could proceed unaided. A descriptive qualitative approach was adopted, entailing inductive thematic analysis.Participants22 physicians experienced in treating patients in situations of language discordance were recruited from the emergency and internal medicine departments of an urban tertiary-care hospital.SettingLarge, inner-city teaching hospital in Toronto, Canada, one of the most linguistically diverse cities internationally.ResultsDetermining when to ‘get by’ or ‘get help’ in order to facilitate communication was described as a fluid and variable process. Deciding which strategy to use depended on three inter-related factors: time/time constraints, acuity of situation and ease of use/availability of translation aids. Participants reported at times feeling conflicted about their decisions, portraying some of these clinical encounters as a ‘troubling space’ in which they experienced one or more dilemmas related to real versus ideal practice, responsibility and informed consent.ConclusionsIn situations of language discordance, a physician's decision to ‘get by’ (vs ‘get help’) rests on a judgement of whether communication can be considered ‘good enough’ to proceed and depends on the circumstances of the specific encounter. The tension set up between what is ‘ideal’ and what is practically possible can be experienced as a dilemma by physicians. The study's findings have implications for practice and policy not only in Canada but in other multilingual settings, and indicate that physicians require greater support.

Care of patients in emergency department waiting rooms – an integrative review

“…, Parsons et al . ). Those performing the roles, therefore, need to have or may need further development of this skill set to ensure patient satisfaction and safe, quality care in the waiting room.…”

Compromised communication: a qualitative study exploring Afghan families and health professionals’ experience of interpreting support in Australian maternity care

“…In a variety of health settings, others have noted that the reality of busy clinics and hospitals including time constraints for clinical contact is a reason health professionals opt for the ‘path of least resistance’ and use family members to interpret 16. Management of time for interpreter-mediated appointments within fiscal constraints is a challenge for health services.…”

“…International literature sheds light on the factors at play for clinicians when communicating in situations of language discordance, and how they decide to ‘get by’ without interpreting support or ‘get help’ from a professional interpreter 16. Studies of clinician–patient communication in paediatric and chronic disease management indicate that ‘getting by’ unaided or using a family member to interpret is common practice, despite recognition that this may lead to more errors in communication and worse clinical outcomes 2 17.…”

Not Just “Getting by”: Factors Influencing Providers’ Choice of Interpreters

“…With only 10 weeks of medical Spanish, providers reduced their use of interpreters and experienced increased patient satisfaction. 35 In short, providers' underuse of professional interpreters should not be simply viewed as problematic 36,37 ; rather, the different ways of communicating with LEP patients should be viewed as complementary, rather than competing or interchangeable.…”