To Do or Not to Do? Neurorrhaphy in Great Toe Pulp Flap Fingertip Reconstruction

Abstract

Background: Since its inception, the great toe pulp (GTP) flap has represented a valid therapeutic choice in the reconstruction of defects of the hand. This study illustrates the clinical outcomes of GTP free flaps performed without nerve anastomosis‚ mainly for fingertip defect reconstruction. Methods: We performed a retrospective, monocentric cohort study. All patients included in this study presented with fingertip traumatic injury, with tendon or bone exposure; reconstruction with GTP flap, without nerve reconstruction, was performed by the first author (L.T.) from May 2019 to October 2021. Results: All 37 flaps survived completely. Due to COVID restrictions‚ we had to send the tests and PROMs to our patients; 28 of them replied. Cold intolerance was reported by 12 patients (moderate in two cases and mild in ten cases). No pain was complained about either in hand or donor site (Visual Analog Score 0, at rest and at movement). Complete range of motion was achieved in 22 of 28 patients. All flaps recovered protective sensitivity. In every section of the Michigan Hand Outcome Questionnaire, all patients expressed a high level of satisfaction based on the reconstruction’s function and aesthetics. Regarding the donor site morbidity, no patient complained about gait disturbance. Conclusions: This study showed that the GTP flap is the optimal choice for fingertip reconstruction, providing excellent functional and aesthetic results with durable and glabrous skin, satisfactory pulp contour, and sensory restoration. These results could be achieved with no need for nerve suture, especially in defects with no injuries proximal to the loss of substance.

Syndactylized glabrous flaps for multiple finger palmar defects

“…Many flaps involve nerves for sensory recovery, such as neurovascular island flaps, but it has been reported that sensory recovery can be achieved by non‐innervated flaps for the fingertip (Kim et al, 2013; Lee et al, 2017; Troisi et al, 2022). We performed nerve coaptation in only two cases (1 and 5).…”