To be seen, confirmed and involved - a ten year follow-up of perceived health and cardiovascular risk factors in a Swedish community intervention programme

Abstract

BackgroundPublic health interventions are directed towards social systems and it is difficult to foresee all consequences. While targeted outcomes may be positively influenced, interventions may at worst be counterproductive. To include self-reported health in an evaluation is one way of addressing possible side-effects. This study is based on a 10 year follow-up of a cardiovascular community intervention programme in northern Sweden.MethodsBoth quantitative and qualitative approaches were used to address the interaction between changes in self-rated health and risk factor load. Qualitative interviews contributed to an analysis of how the outcome was influenced by health related norms and attitudes.ResultsMost people maintained a low risk factor load and a positive perception of health. However, more people improved than deteriorated their situation regarding both perceived health and risk factor load. "Ideal types" of attitude sets towards the programme, generated from the interviews, helped to interpret an observed polarisation for men and the lower educated.ConclusionOur observation of a socially and gender differentiated intervention effect suggests a need to test new intervention strategies. Future community interventions may benefit from targeting more directly those who in combination with high risk factor load perceive their health as bad and to make all participants feel seen, confirmed and involved.

Perfil de risco cardiovascular e autoavaliação da saúde no Brasil: estudo de base populacional

“…Menor aglomeração de fatores de risco foi observada entre aqueles com maior renda e escolaridade, melhor autoavaliação da saúde e entre os indivíduos com relato negativo de DIC e diabetes, corroborando resultados obtidos em outros estudos (3,5,7,12,(29)(30)(31)(32). A relação entre maior educação ou renda e menor carga de fatores de risco cardiovascular pode sugerir maior acesso às informações e aos serviços de saúde, tendo como resultado a prática de comportamentos saudáveis.…”

“…Muitas das variações observadas no perfil individual ou populacional de saúde cardiovascular podem ser compreendidas por meio do estudo da aglomeração de fatores de risco, já que o comportamento desses fatores varia segundo características sociodemográficas, étnicas, geográficas e também quanto à presença de doenças e a percepção da própria saúde (3,(5)(6)(7)(8). Apesar da importância desse tema, o volume de informações de base populacional sobre a aglomeração de fatores de risco cardiovascular (FRCV) na população adulta brasileira ainda é restrito (9)(10)(11).…”

Be SMART: examining the experience of implementing the NHS Health Check in UK primary care

“…A key challenge is communication between HCPs and patients [ 7 ]. A common analogy used to indicate the intended regularity and significance of the check is an ‘MOT’ - a UK motor vehicle check of roadworthiness conducted by the Ministry of Transport - but findings are inconsistent regarding the effectiveness of using this language [ 8 - 10 ].…”

The Italian health surveillance (SiVeAS) prioritization approach to reduce chronic disease risk factors

“…Emmelin et al 2007 10-year follow-up of a Swedish community intervention program 63% of participants with a high level at baseline had low levels at follow-up Community-based intervention to improve self-care, access to care, and quality of care for residents with diabetes (pre-post)…”