Tipping points of ancient Japanese Jomon trade networks from social network analyses of obsidian artifacts

Abstract

The Jomon period of ancient Japan, characterized by hunting and gathering, lasted from 16,000 to 2,400 years cal BP. In this ∼13,000-year period, the geographical range of trade is known to have been extensive but may not have always been constant. We conducted obsidian social network analyses on a large dataset to explore the dynamics of trade networks and their tipping points during the Jomon period. This study clustered sites by geographical location and summarized obsidian artifacts in aggregate values by region to increase regional representativeness. This improved the readability and interpretability of the analysis results and decreased the distortion of results owing to a small sample of sites. The results showed that, for sites adjacent to one another, it is reasonable to group the total values by region and assess the regional representativeness of the findings. Framing the provenance and consumption areas as a bipartite graph and using network analyses among consumption areas revealed that the obsidian trade network expanded throughout the Kanto region in the middle Jomon period (5,500–4,500 years cal BP) but regionalized in the late Jomon period (4,500–3,200 years cal BP). These periods were extracted as tipping points in the Jomon trade network. The timing of these tipping points possibly occurred during a period of major climate change. Therefore, these tipping points of obsidian trade networks may have resulted from population decline and migration caused by shifting coastlines and living infrastructure owing to climate change.

Social Network Analysis of Ancient Japanese Obsidian Artifacts Reflecting Sampling Bias Reduction

“…In addition to the findings from Sakahira and Tsumura (2023), this study:  Evaluated the distribution of cosine similarities among clusters based on obsidian composition by provenance, after clustering using the DBSCAN algorithm. Additionally, the distribution of cosine similarities between sites within a cluster and sites outside of a cluster was assessed.…”

“…Based on the results of clustering using DBSCAN, some clusters were excluded from the analysis, as they contained less than 30 obsidian artifacts. For details of the number of clusters and single sites for each period, as well as the total number and composition ratios of obsidian artifacts by provenance, please refer to Sakahira and Tsumura (2023).…”

“…The results of the social network analysis were described in our previous study (Sakahira & Tsumura, 2023). However, in this study, we have created a new pie chart to show the composition of obsidian from different provenances in each cluster, and we have added it to the network analysis.…”

“…These results suggest that the obsidian trading network developed throughout the southern Kanto region during the Middle Jomon Period and ceased to function during the later period. For more details of these analyses, please refer to Sakahira and Tsumura (2023).…”