Timing of Palliative Care Referral Before and After Evidence from Trials Supporting Early Palliative Care

Abstract

Background Evidence from randomized controlled trials has demonstrated benefits in quality of life outcomes from early palliative care concurrent with standard oncology care in patients with advanced cancer. We hypothesized that there would be earlier referral to outpatient palliative care at a comprehensive cancer center following this evidence. Materials and Methods Administrative databases were reviewed for two cohorts of patients: the pre‐evidence cohort was seen in outpatient palliative care between June and November 2006, and the post‐evidence cohort was seen between June and November 2015. Timing of referral was categorized, according to time from referral to death, as early (>12 months), intermediate (>6 months to 12 months), and late (≤6 months from referral to death). Univariable and multivariable ordinal logistic regression analyses were used to determine demographic and medical factors associated with timing of referral. Results Late referrals decreased from 68.8% pre‐evidence to 44.8% post‐evidence; early referrals increased from 13.4% to 31.1% (p < .0001). The median time from palliative care referral to death increased from 3.5 to 7.0 months (p < .0001); time from diagnosis to referral was also reduced (p < .05). On multivariable regression analysis, earlier referral to palliative care was associated with post‐evidence group (p < .0001), adjusting for shorter time since diagnosis (p < .0001), referral for pain and symptom management (p = .002), and patient sex (p = .04). Late referrals were reduced to <50% in the breast, gynecological, genitourinary, lung, and gastrointestinal tumor sites. Conclusions Following robust evidence from trials supporting early palliative care for patients with advanced cancer, patients were referred substantially earlier to outpatient palliative care. Implications for Practice Following published evidence demonstrating the benefit of early referral to palliative care for patients with advanced cancer, there was a substantial increase in early referrals to outpatient palliative care at a comprehensive cancer center. The increase in early referrals occurred mainly in tumor sites that have been included in trials of early palliative care. These results indicate that oncologists’ referral practices can change if positive consequences of earlier referral are demonstrated. Future research should focus on demonstrating benefits of early palliative care for tumor sites that have tended to be omitted from early palliative care trials.

What are determinants of utilisation of pharmaceutical anticancer treatment during the last year of life in Norway? A retrospective registry study

“…More recently it has become clear that palliative care should start earlier when active therapies are still in use. 3 In this study, we explore those receiving PACT who are not in the terminal phase according to the first definition.…”

“…Initially, terminal phase was defined as the time in which palliative care should be applied instead of active therapies. More recently it has become clear that palliative care should start earlier when active therapies are still in use 3. In this study, we explore those receiving PACT who are not in the terminal phase according to the first definition.…”

Using Process Indicators to Monitor Documentation of Patient-Centred Variables in an Integrated Oncology and Palliative Care Pathway—Results from a Cluster Randomized Trial

“…A traditional assumption has been that presenting convincing evidence-based research results would suffice to an uptake in practice [ 62 ]. A Canadian study compared the timeliness of PC referrals defined as early (12 months) or late (<6 months) before death in two patient cohorts, one from 2006 before the published evidence of early PC referrals, and one from 2017 when the positive benefits were well-known and wide-spread demonstrating a substantial increase in early referrals [ 63 ]. From an implementation point of view, this approach may still work for relatively small and specific changes but based on our experience from the present study and our former work, a more comprehensive approach is necessary.…”

Incorporating palliative care principles to improve patient care and quality of life in urologic oncology

“…the goal of palliation is to prevent and relieve suffering and to support the best possible quality of life for the patient and family". 96 . Not all practices or health care systems can afford the time required to provide primary palliative care in the outpatient setting, with these interventions averaging 17 min in duration to complete 97 .…”