Thriving or Dividing? The Women's Movement and the Independence Referenda in Scotland and Catalonia

Abstract

Territorial debates have recently shaken the political systems in Scotland and Catalonia, leading to referenda on independence. This article engages with questions concerning whether this extraordinary process has affected the women's movement and why. Specifically, feminist scholars have often expressed concern regarding how strong territorial identities and nationalist projects might prove detrimental to the movement's unity and success. Here, I look for indications of engagement and revival within the frames of the Scottish and Catalan referendum campaigns. A comparative approach revealed the mobilizing potential of these contexts when certain conditions were present. While the women's movement in Scotland has thrived in the last couple of years, territorial debates in Catalonia have not provided fertile ground for feminist campaigning and have shown divisive potential. The specific dynamics of the women's movement in each setting and the presence of political and discursive opportunity structures account for the different outcomes.

The Spanish Gender Regime in the EU Context: Changes and Struggles in Times of Austerity

“…Feminist struggles have grown out of the experience of joint political democratic and anti‐austerity projects with other civil society groups. The resurgence of civil society activism that exploded with the Indignados movement, the experience of local political activism in grassroots organizations and citizens' waves, and the participation in anti‐austerity struggles have empowered and revitalized the Spanish feminist movement, making it more effective in the organization and representation of women's interests than former research had found (Alonso, ; Bustelo, ; Clavero, ; García, ; Valiente, ). The successful outcome of feminist pro‐abortion mobilizations — i.e.…”

“…The feminist movement mobilized strongly against what it renamed a ‘counter‐reformist’ bill, by organizing huge demonstrations, reactivating organizations such as the National Platform of Feminist Organizations, and forging national and international alliances (Alonso, ; García, ). The struggle to defend the right of abortion was a success story for the feminist movement.…”

“…Massive national and transnational feminist mobilizations with ‘freedom trains’ converging on Madrid, criticism from feminist members of the European Parliament, internal divergences within the conservative party, and the government's fear that the bill would have a boomerang effect against the ruling party in the year preceding elections, led the prime minister to withdraw the bill and forced the resignation of the minister of justice that proposed it . The campaign revitalized the feminist movement and attracted more young women to the feminist cause (Alonso, ).…”

Políticas de salud sexual y reproductiva en España: Contra-movimientos y marcos interpretativos en conflicto

“…Este ha experimentado un claro incremento en su nivel de movilización, con la creación de nuevas estructuras y una mayor coordinación a nivel estatal, hecho que no había ocurrido en décadas, dado el elevado nivel de fragmentación territorial del mismo (Lombardo, 2016;Alonso, 2016;García, 2015). Este auge del movimiento ha de entenderse en el marco del mayor ataque a los derechos sociales y reproductivos de las mujeres españolas en la etapa democrática.…”

Tragedy Sentimentalism 1965 Short Story in Nyanyian Penggali Kubur by Gunawan Budi Susanto

“…Meanwhile, in North Sumetera, there were around 15,000 people killed, including Chinese ethnic, and around 15,000 others were arrested [2]. It caused [3] bitter experience or traumatic event often haunts the journey of human life. Although it has been buried deeply, bad events at certain moments can be recalled.…”