Three missing dimensions in contemporary studies of identity: The unconscious, negative attributes, and society.

Abstract

Erik Erikson developed a distaste for his concept of identity because it was so frequently misused. He held that identity development is not at an “achievement” or an unalterable accomplishment. He was concerned that certain dimensions of identity had been systematically excluded. To Erikson, three essential dimensions—the unconscious, negatives, and society—were studiously ignored. In operationalizing identity such that its facets are measurable, researchers had underrepresented the construct. In order to return these three dimensions to the identity construct, I first explore Erikson's meaning of the construct. I then examine how he saw the unconscious, social forces, and negating dimensions as attributes that must be included in any portrayal of psychosocial identity. Sources for this paper are Erikson's major publications on identity and his unpublished Harvard papers.

No Longer Silent: An Autobiographical/Biographical Exploration of a School Desegregation Experience

“…The adolescent must move towards what has been described as a largely unconscious process of developing a sense of self and self-worth in order to progress to the next stage of intimacy versus isolation (Hoare 2013). Adolescents in general are about the business of establishing who they are, identifying their values and beliefs, and exploring a sense of identity.…”

Philosophical commitments, empirical evidence, and theoretical psychology

“…When this happens, the chosen operations may encourage unwarranted inferences about those theoretical constructs. Researchers have struggled to operationalize dimensions of the religious and the spiritual that have more than one interpretation in addition to the more mundane features of human experience thought fundamental to social psychological research, such as personal identity (Hoare, 2012). The problems of operationalizing complex theoretical constructs that allow for replicable assessment have resulted in lack of consensus on best practices across social psychological research (Miller & Thoresen, 2003).…”

Peers as an Academic Resource: An Investigation of an Afterschool Program to Socialize At-risk Students with Disabilities into Greater Academic Engagement

“…Cultural attributes and societal norms inform an individual's behavior and whether or not that behavior fits societal norms helps form the individual's sense of identity (Hoare, 2013). During middle and late childhood, the latter part of the stage that Erikson calls industry verses inferiority (circa 10 to 11 years of age), a child's world begins to include more than just the home.…”

“…In Erikson's theory of psychosocial development, cultural attributes and societal norms play an important role in informing an individual's behavior. According to Erikson, the extent to which an individual's behavior fits with societal norms is fundamental to a person's sense of identity (Hoare, 2013).…”

“…By adolescence, each individual has become attuned to particular societal, cultural and national perspectives (Hoare, 2013). Adolescence is a period when the individual "through free role experimentation may find a niche in some section of his society" (Erikson, 1956, p. 66).…”