Three Decades of Research on Smart Cities: Mapping Knowledge Structure and Trends

Abstract

The concept of smart cities has gained significant momentum in science and policy circles over the past decade. This study aims to provide an overview of the structure and trends in the literature on smart cities. Bibliometric analysis and science mapping techniques using VOSviewer and CiteSpace are used to identify the thematic focus of over 5000 articles indexed in the Web of Science since 1991. In addition to providing insights into the thematic evolution of the field, the three-decade study period is divided into two sub-periods (1991–2015 and 2016–2021). While splitting the dataset into more sub-periods would have been desirable, we decided to only examine two sub-periods as only very few papers have been published until 2010. The annual number of publications has progressively increased since then, with a surge in the annual number of publications observable from 2015 onwards. The thematic analysis showed that the intellectual base of the field has been very limited during the first period, but has expanded significantly since 2015. Over time, some thematic evolutions, such as further attention to linkages to climate change and resilience, and more emphasis on security and privacy issues, have been made. The thematic analysis shows that existing research on smart cities is dominated by either conceptual issues or underlying technical aspects. It is, therefore, essential to do more research on the implementation of smart cities and actual and/or potential contributions of smart cities to solving societal issues. In addition to elaborating on thematic focus, the study also highlights major authors, journals, references, countries, and institutions that have contributed to the development of the smart cities literature.

Smart City and Crisis Management: Lessons for the COVID-19 Pandemic

“…One of the main planning tools to reduce the risks and vulnerability of populations is using technology to increase preparedness and recovery capacities in the face of crises. In the urban planning domain, such planning tools, efforts, and initiatives are often referred to as smart city solutions [14]. A smart city has three main pillars, including technology, people and institution.…”

Safety and Risk Analysis of Autonomous Vehicles Using Computer Vision and Neural Networks

“…Additionally, the advancement of machine learning and neural networks can bring far reaching contributions to increasing the precision of autonomous driving, in particular with the introduction of the concept of neuroplasticity [59]. Finally, with the coupling of technology in urban fabrics, leading to the advancement of the concept of smart cities [60][61][62] and the need for more compact yet connected neighbourhoods [63], it is expected that sensors will be able to further communicate with AVs, resulting in even safer driving experiences. This is even expected to be facilitated by upcoming 6G technologies [64].…”

Implementation of “Smart” Solutions and An Attempt to Measure Them: A Case Study of Czestochowa, Poland

“…There are many concepts that describe the idea of a smart city. A literature review in the field of the smart city concept was carried out, among others, by Ramaprasad et al [6], Albino, Berardi, and Dangelico [7], Anthopoulos [8], Gill-Garcia et al [9], Neirotti et al [2], Chourabi et al [10], Chatterjee and Kar [11], Sinkiene et al [12], Kobayashi Kaneko et al [13], Szarifi et al [14], or Mora et al [15]. A review regarding information systems was performed, inter alia, by Ismagilova et al [16].…”