Thoughts on the potential to compensate a hearing loss in noise

Abstract

Background: The effect of hearing impairment on speech perception was described by Plomp (1978) as a sum of a loss of class A, due to signal attenuation, and a loss of class D, due to signal distortion. While a loss of class A can be compensated by linear amplification, a loss of class D, which severely limits the benefit of hearing aids in noisy listening conditions, cannot. The hearing loss of class D is assumed to be the main reason why not few users of hearing aids keep complaining about the limited benefit of their devices in noisy environments. Working compensation strategies against it are unknown. Methods: Recently, in an approach to model human speech recognition by means of a re-purposed automatic speech recognition (ASR) system, the loss of class D was explained by introducing a level uncertainty which reduces the individual accuracy of spectro-temporal signal levels. Based on this finding, an implementation of a patented dynamic range manipulation scheme (PLATT) is proposed which aims to mitigate the effect of increased level uncertainty on speech recognition in noise by expanding spectral modulation patterns in the range of 2 to 4 ERB. This compensation approach is objectively evaluated regarding the benefit in speech recognition thresholds in noise using the ASR-based speech recognition model. Recommendations for an evaluation with human listeners are derived. Results: The objective evaluation suggests that approximately half of the class D loss due to an increased level uncertainty might be compensable. To measure the effect with human listeners, an experiment needs to be carefully designed to prevent the confusion class A and D loss compensations. Conclusions: A working compensation strategy for the class D loss could provide previously unexploited potential for relief. Evidence has to be provided in experiments with human listeners.