The β-scission mechanism of physisorbed and chemisorbed pentenium ions, as catalyzed by AlH2(OH)2 and by AlHCl3 anions, was investigated using density functional theory computations and explicit-contact modelling. A thorough search of intermediates was performed for each catalyst. On the aluminum chloride, β scission of an aliphatic, secondary carbenium ion featured chemisorbed and physisorbed ion intermediates, while on the aluminum hydroxide, β scission featured chemisorbed ions but physisorbed neutral species. The importance of this work is its demonstration of a qualitatively different mechanism, with qualitatively different intermediates, due only to the different basicity of the two catalysts.Key words: CC bond fission, β scission, carbenium ion, catalysis, mechanism.