(1 1. V. 88)Further evidence is presented that the 2-norbomyl cation is stabilized primarily by C(2)-C{6) bridging, and that C(2)-C(7) bridging leads to prohibitive strain. Thus, a comparison of the heats of hydrogenation of nortricyclene 17 and bicycl0[3.2.0.0~.~]heptane 18 indicates that the strain energy of the latter is ca. 21.5 kcal/mol higher than that of 17. Furthermore, 6-exo-2-oxabicyclo[2.2. ljheptyl sulfonates 8 ionize with strong O(2) participation to the bridged oxonium ion 12. In contrast, 2-endo-7-oxabicyclo[2.2.1]heptyl sulfonates 11 ionize without O(7) participation to form the unbridged carbenium ion 15.As pointed out in [la], displacement (&2) reactions of bi-and tricyclic halides and sulfonates with nucleophilic solvents are sterically hindered, if the nucleofuge is adjacent to a bridgehead atom. In these cases, solvolysis reactions occur via carbenium ions (&1) and tend to be slow unless assisted by bridging of the cationic center by neighboring atoms.In carbocyclic compounds, bridging involves weak bonding between the electrophilic cationic center and neighboring C-atoms, thereby generating some of the strain associated with the subdivision of cyclic structures into smaller rings [2]. Differential bridging of neighboring C-atoms, therefore, accounts for the frequently different rates and products of epimeric bi-and tricyclic sulfonates [lb], such as the exo-and endo-2-norbornyl p -bromobenzenesulfonates (brosylates) and p -toluenesulfonates (tosylates) 1 (X = BsO) and 2 (X = TsO), respectively, which differ by factors of more than 3002).In their original communications [3], Winstein and Trifan attributed the higher rate of 1-OBs to anchimeric assistance of exo-ionization by the antiperiplanar C( 1)-C(6) bonding electrons, i.e. by so-called CT participation3), which is absent in the endo-epimer 2-OBs. According to a modified version of this rationale [6], the transition state for exo-ionization is stabilized by C,C hyperconjugation with the strained and antiperiplanar C( 1)-C(6) CT bond. Thus, both interpretations stress the role of the C( 1)-C(6) bonding electrons in controlling the relative rates of I-OBs and 2-OBs. On the other hand, the role of the equally strained C( 1)-C(7) bond, which is somewhat deflected from the plane ')
2,
3,The IUPAC name for norbornane: 8,9,1U-trinorbornane. The rate ratio at 25"is 350 in AcOH [3], 580 in 80% EtOH [lb], and cn. 2000 in H2O [4].For a definition of u participation, see [5].