Elemental white phosphorus (P 4 ) is a key feedstock for the entire phosphorus-derived chemicals industry, spanning everything from herbicides to food additives. The electrochemical reduction of phosphate salts could enable the sustainable production of P 4 ; however, such electrosynthesis requires the cleavage of strong, inert P−O bonds. By analogy to the promotion of bond activation in aqueous electrolytes with high proton activity (Brønsted−Lowry acidity), we show that low oxide anion activity (Lux−Flood acidity) enhances P−O bond activation in molten salt electrolytes. We develop electroanalytical tools to quantify the oxide dependence of phosphate reduction, and find that Lux acidic phosphoryl anhydride linkages enable selective, high-efficiency electrosynthesis of P 4 at a yield of 95% Faradaic efficiency. These fundamental studies provide a foundation that may enable the development of low-carbon alternatives to legacy carbothermal synthesis of P 4 .