Theorising northernness and northern culture: the north of England, northern Englishness, and sympathetic magic

Abstract

Northernness is something that is simultaneously as real as the millstone grit of the Pennines, and as inauthentic as the simulacra Roman texts that gave the hills their name. Drawing on the work of Baudrillard, Anderson and Frazer, this paper offers a strong critique of the 'commonsense' idea of northernness expressed in culture by and about the north. The paper begins by attempting to understand this construct historically and from the inside, anthropologically and sociologically. A discussion of the ways in which northernness is claimed to be constructed and performed through shared myths will allow for a wider analysis of how the north is still constructed hegemonically by outsiders: as an essential place of Othering and wilderness. I argue that previous scholarship about northern culture and northern England has also contributed to this essentialism. It will then be shown how northernness has become a form of Frazerian sympathetic magic, performed and invoked to account for cultural practices and beliefs that have been invoked elsewhere for the purposes of hegemonic power.

Music, Beer and Performativity in New Local Leisure Spaces: Case Study of a Yorkshire Dales Market Town

“…The quirky cafes and bars of the post-industrial city thus constitute stages on which young 'urbanites' assert and project cultural capital, demonstrating cultural competences through a set of aesthetic and ethical choices which set them apart from mainstream tastes and values. The same performativity of 'sense of place' is found in much sociology of leisure research, whether it is the imaginary community at the heart of sports fandom (Spracklen, 2016;Spracklen et al, 2010), or various alternative music scenes (Spracklen and Spracklen, 2014;Spracklen, 2017) But whilst the urban hipster's claims on authentic place and space are well documented, as Sharon Zukin (2011) argues, gentrification and local entrepreneurialism are also evident in the construction of authentic sense of place in at least some rural areas of both Britain and North America. Amongst the emergent practices evident in new local leisure spaces is that of combining alcohol and music related leisure.…”

Workington Man, Brexit and populism: discussions of politics, identity and class among rugby league fans online

“…Through the history of rugby league and rugby union in the UK, between 1895 and 1995, rugby union was the game of the middle and upper classes of England, played in private schools, universities, the military and in clubs enculturated in the cult of the gentleman amateur (Collins 2006(Collins , 2015Spracklen 2016;Spracklen and Spracklen 2020). 6 Sports reporters in the press, on radio, then on television, promoted this privileged position of rugby union.…”

“…Neither Gove, nor Conservative Leader and Prime Minister Boris Johnson, have ever invoked knowledge of rugby league, nor shown any real interest in it, as far as we can ascertain by searching news archives. Ignoring the strained logic of the analogy, the point is that Gove, a man who attended an elite private school in Scotland then went to Oxford University, a man one would expect to only ever play or watch rugby union, all of a sudden is talking about rugby league: the game associated with the post-industrial towns of the north of England (Collins 1999(Collins , 2006Spracklen 2016).…”

Saturated with meaning: peatlands, heritage and folklore

“…The northern moors, in particular, have been framed by writers (e.g. the BrontöLaw/Grubstone (Historic Englands) as wild and alien (Spracklen 2016). At the same time, some factual aspects occur within the popular literature.…”