The isolation of the branched alkenyl intermediate that
directly precedes reductive elimination of the final α,β-unsaturated
ketone product is reported for the hydroacylation reaction between
the alkyne HCCArF (ArF = 3,5-(CF3)2C6H3) and the β-S-substituted
aldehyde 2-(methylthio)benzaldehyde: [Rh(fac-κ3-DPEphos)(C(CH2)ArF)(C(O)C6H4SMe)2][CB11H12]. The structure of this intermediate shows that, in this system
at least, hydride migration rather than acyl migration occurs. Kinetic
studies on the subsequent reductive elimination to form the crystallographically
characterized ketone-bound product [Rh(cis-κ2-DPEphos)(η2:η2,κ1-H2CC(ArF)C(O)(C6H4SMe)][CB11H12] yield the
following activation parameters for reductive elimination, which follows
first-order kinetics (k
obs = (6.14 ±
0.04) × 10–5 s–1, 324 K):
ΔH
⧧ = 95 ±
2 kJ mol–1, ΔS
⧧ = −32 ± 7 J K–1 mol–1, ΔG
⧧(298 K) = 105 ± 4 kJ mol–1.
Mechanistic studies, including selective deuteration experiments,
show that hydride insertion is not reversible and also reveal that
an interesting isomerization process is occurring between the two
branched alkenyl protons that is suggested to occur via a metallocyclopropene
intermediate. During catalysis, the consumption of substrates and
evolution of products follow pseudo zero-order kinetics. The observation
of both linear and branched products under stoichiometric and catalytic
regimes, in combination with kinetic modeling, allows for an overall
mechanistic scheme to be presented. Partitioning of linear and branched
pathways at the hydride insertion step occurs with an approximate
2:1 selectivity, while reductive elimination of the linear product
is at least 3 orders of magnitude faster than that from the branched.
An explanation for the large difference in rate of reductive elimination
in this system, as recently outlined by Goldman, Krogh-Jespersen,
and Brookhart, is that steric crowding in branched intermediates can
slow C–C reductive elimination even though such species are
higher in energy than their linear analogues, if the rotation of the
vinyl group to the appropriate orientation is inhibited by steric
crowding in the branched isomers.