Considerable evidence suggests that the S-nitrosation of cysteine residues, thought to regulate the activities of many proteins, is involved in the uptake and intracellular trafficking of NO. 1 Indeed, to absorb the neutral NO with thiols, a redox reaction is needed to form Snitrosothiols (RSNOs). [1][2][3] A structure of S-nitrosocysteine in hemoglobin proteins was first reported by Arnone and coworkers in 1998. 4a Interestingly, the resulting protein structure obtained under nonbiological conditions (NO pressure, anaerobic) exhibits unexpected C-S-N-O dihedral angles of 88° and -76° for Cys93 of β1 and β2 subunits. The crystallographic results contradict the planar geometries of all RSNOs in small molecule crystallographic data, 5 and from quantum mechanical calculations. 6 Recently, Arnone et al. refined the X-ray data again and reported that the electron density of the SNO-Cys98(F9)β could not be fit with a planar syn or an anti S-nitrosothiol model. They found C-S-N-O dihedral angles between 70° and 90° for SNO-Cys93(F9)β1 and SNO-Cys93(F9)β2. (Fig. 1) 4b To explain this, they proposed that a N-centered radical, Cys-S-N·-OH, was present and stabilized by hydrogen bonding with Val98. Such a radical was previously proposed as an intermediate in reactions of NO with thiols. 7 However, the SNO moiety in the Cys93(F9)β2 subunit is unlikely to be stabilized in this way, because the shortest O---O distance between the oxygen atom of the studied SNO species and the nearest oxygen of Lys144 is about 3.84 Å, a distance too long for significant OH---O hydrogen bonding interactions.By contrast, Montfort and coworkers have reported that the nitric oxide transport protein, nitrophorin cNP, 8 couples reduction and oxidation of a heme moiety with reversible Snitrosation of a cysteine residue (PDB: 1Y21). This S-nitrosothiol species has a C-S-N-O dihedral angle of 0°, coinciding with a planar CSNO geometry in small molecule crystallographic data. The cysteine sulfide coordinating to ferric heme is the key to the Snitrosothiol formation in this protein. Unlike nitrophorins, the NO-bound cysteine in hemoglobin is 10 Å (Fe---S) from the closest heme.To determine the identity of the ~90° CSNO moiety in the purported S-nitrosohemoglobin, we have explored all four types of SNO species (RSNO, RS-N·-OH, RS-NH-O·, and RS-NH-OH) that could be candidates for the observed SNO species, using simple models (R = Me) that can be computed at a high level. By comparison of the calculated structures to the experimental crystallographic data, we have discovered that the thionitroxide radical (Cys-S-NH-O·) is consistent with the observed SNO structures in both β1 and β2 subunits.Correspondence to: K. N. Houk. Supporting Information Available: Complete reference 9, the NO-modified hemoglobin, and the detailed structures and energetics of stationary points on potential energy surfaces of the four SNO species. These materials are available free of charge via the Internet at http://pubs.acs.org.
NIH Public AccessAuthor Manuscript J Am Chem Soc...