The wounds that do not heal: Black expendability and the traumatizing aftereffects of anti-Black police violence

Abstract

PurposeThe murders of Black people at the hands of police in 2020 have led to global protests that have called on public officials to defund or abolish the police. What has been drowned out in these conversations, however, is the traumatizing aftereffects of anti-Black police violence as a public health crisis. In this paper, I argue that the racial terrorism of anti-Black police violence is a deeply felt wound in Black communities that extends beyond the individuals who directly experience it and that this type of collective trauma must be understood as an urgent public health crisis.Design/methodology/approachUsing published studies and online commentaries on anti-Black police violence and its mental health impacts in Canada and the United States, this paper examines the mental health impacts of anti-Black police violence at both the individual and community levels.FindingsA public health response to the traumatizing aftereffects of anti-Black police violence and other forms of state violence must highlight important policy imperatives, such as policies of action focused on improving the public health system. It must also encompass a recognition that the public health crisis of anti-Black police violence is not solvable solely by public health agencies alone. Rather, strategic opportunities to address this crisis arise at every level of governmental interaction, including law enforcement, health care, employment, business, education and the media.Originality/valueWhile the impact of anti-Black police violence on the mental health of Black individuals has been emerging in the literature over the last several years, what has been less focused on and what I address in this paper is how the threat of that violence lingers in Black communities long after the protestors have packed up their megaphones, resulting in collective trauma in Black communities.

“It Stays with You for Life”: The Everyday Nature and Impact of Police Violence in Toronto’s Inner-City

“…Importantly, it must be recognized that a public health approach alone will not end police violence. To address this public health crisis, a multifaceted approach that involves strategic—and where possible collaborative—actions from across sectors, including, but not limited to government, health, education, and police organizations is necessary to holistically address police violence [ 37 ]. The individual and collective trauma resulting from police violence requires both: (a) macro-level policy development that can address the structural inequalities that influence the conditions which allow police violence to persist, such as racial discrimination; and (b) the micro-level policies and practices that leave victims with unmet healthcare needs and impede them from seeking redress, such as police officer accountability, education for teachers and healthcare providers, reducing mental health stigma as it relates to police violence, and increasing access to mental health services.…”

“…Yet, beyond the public health implications of police harassment and violence documented among this population, we continue to know little about the health impacts of police violence on people living in/spending time in marginalized neighbourhoods in Canada. Thus, although some Canadian work has provided rich accounts of the hardships inner-city residents are subject to, including over-policing and neighbourhood violence, there is little empirical data on the individual and community level effects of police violence [ 37 ].…”

Black lives matter: On the denial of systemic racism, White liberals, and polite racism

“…One explanation for the persistence of racism despite decades of anti-racist efforts is the denial of systemic racism. Even in Canada, which has been touted for its tolerance, welcoming attitudes toward immigrants and refugees, and espousing an official policy of multiculturalism, incidents of police brutality and violence against Black and Indigenous Canadians are frequent and widespread (Estrada, 2020, also see Waldron, 2020). Influential White Canadian journalist Rex Murphy, along with politicians and premiers question or deny the existence of systemic racism.…”

“…(Globe and Mail, June 10, 2020) If politicians and civil servants are ever "confused" or cannot comprehend the definition of systemic racism (see Feagin, 2013, for a definition), they need to look no further than to the statistics on unequal outcomes for Blacks and racially oppressed groups particularly in major life domains such as employment, housing, health, education and the criminal justice system (see Bell, 2020;Danso and Grant, 2000;Galabuzi, 2006;Gilbert et al, 2016;Owusu-Bempah and Wortley, 2014;Slaughter, 2020). In the words of Ingrid Waldron (2020), author and producer of There's Something in the Water, ". .…”

Linking Chemistry to Community: Integration of Culturally Responsive Teaching into General Chemistry I Laboratory in a Remote Setting

“…The student population served, and the community surrounding MSU, was among the hardest hit by the pandemic in the state . Furthermore, the year 2020 was also a year of trauma for African Americans, with countless examples of videos on television and social media that showed police violence against African American bodies. − The systemic racial injustices that are an everyday part of their lives were brought to the forefront. − It was time to move chemistry from a book on the shelf into a tool for equity for our students.…”