The working classes and higher education: Meritocratic fallacies of upward mobility in the United Kingdom

Abstract

The uniformly positive view of social mobility in the United Kingdom overlooks the difficulties working‐class young people have in reconciling a working‐class background with the middle‐class environments of the university and the professional labour market. But even more hidden are the subtle processes of exclusion and exclusivity that permeate social life in, particularly, the elite universities. Here, working‐class students' marginalisation in relation to advantageous social activities and networks, compromises their chances of later success in the labour market. This paper scrutinises working‐class students' experiences of elite higher education through the lens of Bourdieu's concepts of habitus, capitals and field. Drawing on a research project on working‐class young people who gain entry to elite universities it analyses the disjunctures between working‐class habitus and the field of elite higher education, focusing on the emotional and social consequences for working‐class students. The findings raise concerns—largely unexplored in existing research—about working‐class reception in elite fields. The paper concludes with a call to look beyond the attitudes and actions of working‐class students to those of their upper‐ and middle‐class peers, and the culture and ethos of the elite universities.

Understanding the relationship between income and mental health among 16- to 24-year-olds: Analysis of 10 waves (2009–2020) of Understanding Society to enable modelling of income interventions

“…As a result, opportunities for those with better or improving mental health to take advantage of it economically and to enhance their income are reducing, especially for young people. The cost of radically increasing income through training, acquisition of materials or resources, etc., is historically high (e.g., Reay [ 50 ]). As such, people’s income is likely to follow fairly stable trajectories for their own sectors of employment or sources of welfare, with large changes in income the result of significant life events, such as trauma, and serious mental health crises which, again, disproportionately occur at the lower end of the SES spectrum, or outlying luck.…”

Well‐being of higher education consumers: A review and research agenda

“…This large‐scale massification has resulted in a highly competitive higher education setting where students are experiencing immense pressure to be successful (Wass et al., 2020). Research also indicates that this expansion may be driving class‐based inequalities (Reay, 2021), further adding to the stress of students. Consequently, student well‐being (SWB) is a significant concern, attracting much attention in recent times (Abbas et al., 2020).…”

“…This social structure of competition may serve as a systemic source of anxiety and stress (Posselt & Lipson, 2016). Furthermore, studies also highlight that this expansion can increase class‐related inequalities (Reay, 2021). Students from more advantaged social backgrounds find themselves better placed to take up new educational opportunities that crop up with expansion (Boliver, 2011).…”

¿Contribuye la gratuidad a la permanencia en la educación superior? Percepciones de estudiantes acerca de su experiencia universitaria

“…Sin embargo, no siempre los estudiantes logran integrarse de buena manera. En efecto, diferentes estudios realizados en el Reino Unido dan cuenta de las dificultades de integración universitaria enfrentadas por los estudiantes de la clase trabajadora, las que pueden suponer riesgos en su permanencia en la universidad (Reay, 2015(Reay, , 2021.…”